Top 5 Most UNdeserving title holders

[czars_salad]

1. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam - Paper champ who keeps backing out of an Arce fight. Fights only in his country Thailand most of the time.

2. Juan Manuel Marquez - Defended title against Salido who? and Polo who?, when a bunch of other fights can be made for him...named Pacman, Morales, Barrera, Injin Chi, Scott etc.
And now will fight Chris who? just so he can get his precious belt back.
3. All the Heavyweights

4. jermaine taylor -- has to be winky.. they must fight to prove his worth

[Super_Lightweight]

hmm

im not saying ruiz fough dirty im saying shots landed to backhead, shotslanded when holding and punches on albows and shoulders dont ****.

especially the combos are hard to tell fore the untrained eye.

That's why you're an amatuer ref...sorry bud.

Ruiz won, and everyone knows it. Not only that, but Valuev lost against Larry Donald. No one who loses to him deserves a title.

Klitschko was deserving. Manny P being an idiot like usual. Klitschko got his off of a legit win.

[butterfly1964]

ernie terrel, jimmy ellis, primo carnera, jack sharkey, and nicolay valuev.

go here!

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=57044

[leff]

That's why you're an amatuer ref...sorry bud.

Ruiz won, and everyone knows it. Not only that, but Valuev lost against Larry Donald. No one who loses to him deserves a title.

Klitschko was deserving. Manny P being an idiot like usual. Klitschko got his off of a legit win.

dude its kinda hard to be the ref in pro fights when pro fights are illegal here, but the course i took works for both ammature and queensberry.


do you think ruiz should be given points for rabbit punchin, hitting while holding and punches landed to arms and shoulders.
if you do you could give it to ruiz.

valuev controlled the fight and landed more clean shots, in other words he won and deserved to

[blockhead]

valuev
vitali
taylor
byrd
rahman

[masterdirector]

Since Ruiz wasn't the real champ in the first place, Valuev couldn't be considered one.

Valuev
Vitali
Ruiz
Hatton for the WBA title (waited until Harris got upset to go after it)
Diego Corrales

Corrales lost both times to Casamayor and Castillo in my eyes, they ****ed Casamayor in the 2nd match, Corrales bitched out of a rematch. Castillo lost to Casamayor but they gave him the huge bull**** win just to make the Corrales vs. Castillo match. Corrales should've been counted out in Castillo 1, or at least not given over 10 seconds, then Castillo is stopped b/c he doesn't go to the canvas. Then of course Castillo knocked Corrales out in 4 in the rematch, so of course Corrales doesn't deserve his titles. Yes, Castillo came in overweight, but Corrales lost, so he should've just been stripped, vacant titles.

[czars_salad]

Since Ruiz wasn't the real champ in the first place, Valuev couldn't be considered one.

Valuev
Vitali
Ruiz
Hatton for the WBA title (waited until Harris got upset to go after it)
Diego Corrales

IMO hatton is fit for the title... he can legitimize it by fighting and winning against PBF

[masterdirector]

IMO hatton is fit for the title... he can legitimize it by fighting and winning against PBF

I don't really care that he has it. Harris didn't deserve it either. But neither did Tszyu since he didn't defend it for well over a year. So I'm fine with Hatton having it, although he got it in a bull**** way, which is why I call him undeserving. Had he not ducked Harris, which hell if Maussa beat Harris, Hatton should have, then I'd say he definitely deserved it. Hatton gave up his #1 contendership though.

Hatton probably isn't the top 5 undeserving, but I didn't want to just keep repeating everyone.

[czars_salad]

I don't really care that he has it. Harris didn't deserve it either. But neither did Tszyu since he didn't defend it for well over a year. So I'm fine with Hatton having it, although he got it in a bull**** way, which is why I call him undeserving. Had he not ducked Harris, which hell if Maussa beat Harris, Hatton should have, then I'd say he definitely deserved it. Hatton gave up his #1 contendership though.

Hatton probably isn't the top 5 undeserving, but I didn't want to just keep repeating everyone.

did he really ducked harris? then is he going to duck pbf too? hahaha! i really dont know much of hatton's way of handling his career... but by beating KT was my basis..

but you have the right words... that he is not "purely deserving" with the title he has.

[masterdirector]

did he really ducked harris? then is he going to duck pbf too? hahaha! i really dont know much of hatton's way of handling his career... but by beating KT was my basis..

but you have the right words... that he is not "purely deserving" with the title he has.

Well Hatton was the number 1 contender and the WBA was to order the purse bid or negotiations to begin and Hatton gave up the #1 contendership. And Harris had already been calling Hatton out for at least a year prior. He even gladly offered to go to England. Cause he went to Germany and beat Urkal twice.