Who Wins: Manny Pacquiao vs. Sergio Martinez at 154 Lbs.

[MurkaMan]

Sergio: A natural 154 lbs'er vs Manny: a natural 130 lbs'er

That's a fair fight.

How about Sergio fights at 149 to even it up since Manny has never weighed more than 147 ever.

Wrong, Manny was 150 on fightnight against Bradley. Steward seemed shock that Manny was lying about his weight all this time, and coming in under 50lb against Marg, ONLY so he could keep his speed.

[lparm]

Wrong, Manny was 150 on fightnight against Bradley. Steward seemed shock that Manny was lying about his weight all this time, and coming in under 50lb against Marg, ONLY so he could keep his speed.

And he weighed in at 150 lbs for the official weigh in???

If you want to play the fight night game them Sergio is easily a super mw not a true light mw.

[MurkaMan]

And he weighed in at 150 lbs for the official weigh in???

If you want to play the fight night game them Sergio is easily a super mw not a true light mw.

You said Manny NEVER weighed in above 150! Thats not true. Manny is the same as Floyd. They both weigh in at 47, and come in at 150. If Pac fought at 54, he would do the same as Floyd. Weigh in at 150, then because of his natural lack of size, he will accidentally come in at 148, just like Floyd. Sometimes he comes in at 147, 148 when he fights at 54, because he is naturally a small guy. Both fighters must be treated equally in this situation.

[timboslice708]

Any time you have a fight with the caliber of guys like Manny and Floyd. You can never count them out. As long as their "within" their weight parameters.

Anyone saying Martinez shuts him down is ******ed. Anyone that says Pacquiao shuts him down is ******ed.

[MurkaMan]

Any time you have a fight with the caliber of guys like Manny and Floyd. You can never count them out. As long as their "within" their weight parameters.

Anyone saying Martinez shuts him down is ******ed. Anyone that says Pacquiao shuts him down is ******ed.

Martinez shuts him down. He beats both, but kills Pac. Simple and plain man.

[Fighting_Pride]

You said Manny NEVER weighed in above 150! Thats not true. Manny is the same as Floyd. They both weigh in at 47, and come in at 150. If Pac fought at 54, he would do the same as Floyd. Weigh in at 150, then because of his natural lack of size, he will accidentally come in at 148, just like Floyd. Sometimes he comes in at 147, 148 when he fights at 54, because he is naturally a small guy. Both fighters must be treated equally in this situation.

on pacquiao-marquez 4, pacquiao rehydrated above 150. with a little bit more push, i think he can actually make 154, but at what cost. same goes to martinez, the last time he made 154 was in 2009. no one would have enormous advantage going into this fight, both pacquiao and martinez would be at even par.