Mayweather@154 or Ward@168, which Sergio Martinez victory would be more impressive?

[The Viper]

And why? Also if he beat both where would you rank him all time?

[Mato o Muero]

Ward. Sergio is bigger than Floyd, and Floyd is still great but he's past his prime. Ward could be fighting at 175 if he wanted to, and is still in his prime.

[k1llu]

ward @168 is more impressive. floyd was never that great @154 but i still think he gets beat by both.

[puga]

ward man ..not even close ...the best at the higher divison >>>the best at the lower diviosn esp if they are both p4p...

[Check_hooks]

Ward and it isn't even close

Not only is Ward above floyd P4P but floyd just got his ass beat by Cotto at 154

[Assteroid Field]

Ward. There's nothing very impressive about beating a smaller, relatively past prime fighter (as good as that fighter may still be).

[Boxing Bob]

Ignorant post from Check_hooks as usual. Ward isn't above Floyd P4P yet and Cotto didn't come close to beating Floyd. Nothing surprising from the Pac nutthugger section.

As for the thread, for casual fans a win over Floyd would be. For hardcore boxing fans it would be Ward for the reasons already mentioned

[devildg]

Ward is a better boxer currently as he's been more active, of course its Ward

[devildg]

Ignorant post from Check_hooks as usual. Ward isn't above Floyd P4P yet and Cotto didn't come close to beating Floyd. Nothing surprising from the Pac nutthugger section.

As for the thread, for casual fans a win over Floyd would be. For hardcore boxing fans it would be Ward for the reasons already mentioned

hey may not be above, but his activity and opponents fought is far more impressive and credible, plus he's naturally bigger which makes a victory over Ward more impressive

[Light_Speed]

Ward because he's prime and at his best weight. Floyd is more skilled but not by much.