Better resume: Mayweather or Hopkins???

[Cardinal Buck]

close but clear, hopkins takes it because he beat a prime ATG in trinidad

^That fight was the equivalent of Floyd's win over Marquez. Both were in the wrong weight class.

And before you come with the "Trinidad was a champion" defense, Marquez came back to the same weight class and beat the consensus php #1 by most accounts.

[The Tase]

who has fought the better opposition?

Bhop

prime roy jones jr
semi prime oscar
prime tito trinidad
prime calzaghe
prime dawson 2x
prime pascal 2x
Tarver
prime jermaine Taylor 2x
Kelly Pavlik


do i even need to post floyds?

its clearly bernard hopkins.

[Grimgash]

how are floyd's "big wins" better than Hopkins? Floyds big wins are Diego Corrales, Castillo and Oscar. I don't think that can quite compare to say Trinidad, Tarver, Pavlik/Pascal

Trinidad was impressive. I would put Floyd vs Hatton above Pavlik tbh. Trinidad and Corrales were respectively two of the best performances in this era in terms of pure domination. Floyd has more big wins than those listed though, in comparison. Outside of the top 3 you move a bit down the list and Floyds top fights outweigh Bernards, though keep going deeper overall Hopkins fought better overall competition.

[I Love Jesus!]

Waaah. Waaaaah.

wow nice come back. Since you only know a couple fighters who's your favorite and how jammed full of all time greats is his resume

Man you must be so tough if you think all these boxers are no named bums. I bet you've kicked so many a$$e$?

[Grimgash]

who has fought the better opposition?

Bhop

prime roy jones jr
semi prime oscar
prime tito trinidad
prime calzaghe
prime dawson 2x
prime pascal 2x
Tarver
prime jermaine Taylor 2x
Kelly Pavlik


do i even need to post floyds?

its clearly bernard hopkins.

Yeah if you're basing it SOLELY on who he fought, but resumes also go to include win-loss when talking about who is better. In which case a lot of that resume would be wiped off the list.

[SplitSecond]

^That fight was the equivalent of Floyd's win over Marquez. Both were in the wrong weight class.

And before you come with the "Trinidad was a champion" defense, Marquez came back to the same weight class and beat the consensus php #1 by most accounts.

oh shoot, you're right, forgot it was trinidads first fight at the wieght where he was fat and hitting 40

[I Love Jesus!]

^That fight was the equivalent of Floyd's win over Marquez. Both were in the wrong weight class.

And before you come with the "Trinidad was a champion" defense, Marquez came back to the same weight class and beat the consensus php #1 by most accounts.

wow you are really pulling at straws even for a floyd homer. If you love him so much why don't you guys go get married?

[deliveryman]

who has fought the better opposition?

Bhop

prime roy jones jr [lost]
semi prime oscar
prime tito trinidad
prime calzaghe [lost]
prime dawson 2x [lost]
prime pascal 2x
Tarver
prime jermaine Taylor 2x [lost] x2
Kelly Pavlik


do i even need to post floyds?

its clearly bernard hopkins.

I find it amusing that you ignore the outcomes of half the fights you mentioned.

[boliodogs]

i understand what you're getting at but i wouldn't have included hakkar on that list. that was actually one of the most pitiful and cowardly performances i've seen in a championship fight. it's kind of insulting to hopkins to include him, and insulting to the fighters you listed him amongst haha

I am sorry I included him. I will take your word that he is no good since I watched many of Hopkin's fights but certainly not all 20 of his defenses. I assumed Hakker was good because of his record but that can be misleading as some fighters get a good record by fighting lousy fighters.

[Cardinal Buck]

wow nice come back. Since you only know a couple fighters who's your favorite and how jammed full of all time greats is his resume

Man you must be so tough if you think all these boxers are no named bums. I bet you've kicked so many a$$e$?

Wah. Wah. Wah.