Question for the boxing purist!!!

[Light_Speed]

I would go with the Floyd win because both Floyd and B-hop were underdogs against unbeaten opponents known for their ko power but Chico at least went on to still have some meaningful wins and after the B-hop loss Tito really didn't.

That's because Bhop ruined him, which makes it even more impressive.

[Spray_resistant]

That's because Bhop ruined him, which makes it even more impressive.

Floyd's win was an utter destruction, it was far more impressive.

[FRANKGWJ]

Anybody who fight B-Hop, career goes down the drain. Latest victim Bad Chad Dawson

[FRANKGWJ]

That's because Bhop ruined him, which makes it even more impressive.

Anybody who fight B-Hop, career goes down the drain. Latest victim Bad Chad Dawson

[Light_Speed]

Anybody who fight B-Hop, career goes down the drain. Latest victim Bad Chad Dawson

Yup B-Hop is the soul taker.

[FRANKGWJ]

Yup B-Hop is the soul taker.

They don't call him the executioner for nothing!!!

[_original_]

Floyd's win was an utter destruction, it was far more impressive.

Sure, comparing the performances themselves, one might think Floyd's victory was more impressive due to the knock downs. But let's compare the opponents they were both facing.

Tito > Chico

[crold1]

Which was the greater preformance?
Mayweather vs Corrales
Hopkins vs Trinidad

We're at the Barber Shop having this huge debate on these two matches and about 75% of 30 people in here chose Hopkins because of hit age and he was a huge underdog!!!

I'd say Hopkins because Tito was a better fighter than Chico and Tito let loose the whole kitchen sink in 6 and 10 and couldn't do anything. Mayweather was dazzling but given court issues and weight issues going in, there was at least a slim question of whether he could have done a little better. I think Tito fought as well as he could and still couldn't do anything because Hopkins was having the night of his life.

[FRANKGWJ]

I'd say Hopkins because Tito was a better fighter than Chico and Tito let loose the whole kitchen sink in 6 and 10 and couldn't do anything. Mayweather was dazzling but given court issues and weight issues going in, there was at least a slim question of whether he could have done a little better. I think Tito fought as well as he could and still couldn't do anything because Hopkins was having the night of his life.

Can you say killer feints!!! B-Hop did what he wanted to do all night long and there was nothing Tito could do about it!!!

[4Corners]

Mayweather-Corrales.

Hopkins beating Trinidad was huge, a great win. But Trinidad was best at WW, by far.

Corrales was the man at 130, and many thought Floyd would lose too. And Floyd gave one of the most dominant beatdowns between two Top 10 P4P fighters in recent memory.