Miguel Cotto vs. Ricky Hatton at 140 pounds. Who would have won?

[Earl-Hickey]

Miguel cotto wasn't that good at 140, well he's not that good full stop but you know what I mean.

I think Ricky wins, but Ricky is undersized at 147 so cotto wins there

But cotto is one of the most overrated fighters of the current era so will win the poll

[El Angel]

Miguel Cotto.

[Earl-Hickey]

Mr. Fantastic, how do you think Hatton would have done against Margarito?

Ricky Hatton was a 140lb fighter that fought at 140, Margarito is AT LEAST a 160lb fighter that fought at 147


Why do people ignore **** like that?

[revs1227]

Hatton woulda stopped him prime he was tougher had a better chin at 140 than cotto
crazy fight hatton stops him

[danceswithfire]

60/40 fight in favor of cotto..hatton would've made it close becuase of his style...but prime for prime, cotto was the better fighter imo

[Sweet Pea 50]

Damn, poor Ricky is getting beat pretty badly in the poll, innit.

[JmH Reborn]

Hatton I think has the style to bother Cotto, but not the size nor strength. Cotto is a better, more finese boxer and I think he'd pick apart a charging Hatton every step of the way and then move the fight foward into a prolonged and I think ugly beating. I think Hatton charges the first four rounds, absorbing punishment, trying to bully Cotto, but Cotto timing him, tagging his body and wearing him down before just brutalizing him in the second half. It'd be a fun fight, and its always been a fantasy fight, because the two mesh well.

I have a secret...if Ricky wins in impressive fashion 2 or 3 fights, I wouldn't mind seeing it

[Jam Jars]

Hatton I think has the style to bother Cotto, but not the size nor strength. Cotto is a better, more finese boxer and I think he'd pick apart a charging Hatton every step of the way and then move the fight foward into a prolonged and I think ugly beating. I think Hatton charges the first four rounds, absorbing punishment, trying to bully Cotto, but Cotto timing him, tagging his body and wearing him down before just brutalizing him in the second half. It'd be a fun fight, and its always been a fantasy fight, because the two mesh well.

I have a secret...if Ricky wins in impressive fashion 2 or 3 fights, I wouldn't mind seeing it

You make Cotto sound like he's Mayweather. If anyone would have faded in the second half it would have been Cotto.

[savorduhflavor]

Two different levels of fighter. Hatton is a full step below Cotto. Cotto would have carved him up something ugly.

Cotto by stoppage, probably by cuts or swelling. Pretty one sided but exciting.

[Jam Jars]

Two different levels of fighter. Hatton is a full step below Cotto. Cotto would have carved him up something ugly.

Cotto by stoppage, probably by cuts or swelling. Pretty one sided but exciting.

Have you actually seen any of Cotto's fights at 140? He was far from being a step up from Hatton.