Why not P4P #1 Andre Ward

[Hougigo]

Because Mayweather is still active

[MR. V]

He's number one in my book. Never lost a fight in his life, takes on all-comers, won the super six tourney without breaking a sweat, and just knocked out the light heavyweight champion of the world. Not much more to say.

[crold1]

Can any body give me 1 reason why Andre Ward should not be P4P number 1. Look at all the competition he has fought in the last 3 year and the way he has beat them easily!!! Bika, Kessler, Froch, Abraham, Green, Maranda and now he stops BAD Chad Dawson easily!! Wow!!!

There's a hell of a case. Ward might not have all the "more" others do but he has something getting beyond the likes of Mayweather, Pacquiao, and Marquez.

Prime.

This reminded me of how I felt after Mayweather-Corrales where it was pretty clear that guys like Jones and Hopkins might have more accomplishments in total but Floyd had reached a point where he was peak and they weren't qwuite anymore.

[boxingfeind]

Though I don't think Ward is there yet (P4P #1), being in multiple weight classes means nothing. Securing your title in one weight class and defending it, unifying, fighting the best names that division has to offer is just as impressive and should be counted in the P4P criteria.

He could've easily won one title, and ran off to 175, like a lot of these P4P guys do. I'm getting a little bored with all these guys climbing through the divisions, trying to be "Money Makers". Guys like Donaire or thelatest one being this Guerrero guy.

Stay in one weight class, and try to be the best Welter/Middle/Light-Heavyweight that you can be.

Its more difficult beating top fighters moving up weight classes then beating top fighters in the same weight class,why do you think Ward did`nt want to move up to fight Dawson?

[Sheppirino]

Pacquiao ain't even in the conversation no more, hasn't been in it for a while. When was the last time he actually performed?

In the eyes of the press and the majority of the fans Pac will at least be in the top 2. I thought he lost to Marquez by 115-113 but I thought he beat Bradley at least 8-4. As much as some people might not like it Pac will always be in the conversation until he either retires or someone comes along and totally outclasses his ass or KO's him.

[boxingfeind]

I`m not giving him no credit for beating a zombie.

[Vasyl’s dad]

He's number one in my book. Never lost a fight in his life, takes on all-comers, won the super six tourney without breaking a sweat, and just knocked out the light heavyweight champion of the world. Not much more to say.

Well thats the eñd of this thread.


SOG number one fighter in the world, with nobody close.

[Carpe Diem]

He's P4P # 2 on my list.

[MR. V]

I`m not giving him no credit for beating a zombie.

Zombies are known for eating brains, killing people, and never dying. How the hell are you not giving him credit? WTF.

[Rip Chudd]

He moves into the #1 spot on my list after tonight.