Where do you rate Floyd among the ATGs?

[Kagami Taiga]

"Doesn't even" shouldn't really follow Top 50.

Being amongst the top 50 fighters of all time in a sport as rich in history as boxing is a huge compliment.

As for Wladimir Klitschko, he is of course no where near the Top 50 or 100.

lol, you are correct. i was trying more to make a point than down talk the top 50. but yes the point is vlad doesnt crack to top 50.

[4Corners]

Wlad doesn't crack the Top 100, he's not an ATG to me. H2H he probably is, but based on career, era, and resume, he doesn't.

[mrcupide2]

Mayweather is easily 1-10

[Alx.]

21-50 for sure

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Top 15-25......


Hes a legend its 2012 hes been boxing since 1996. Its time people got the **** over it and realized hes special.

[thepower]

From the options given, 21-50 is about right. It could have been higher had he been more active and taken certain fights at the right time.

[slickrick9783]

Mayweather is a great fighter. Legitimate champion in 3 weight classes (You could make a case for 4), won belts in 5 weight classes. Never been stopped, never legitimately knocked down. Best Compubox stats of any fighter ever tracked. Top 10 easy. He might have not been in an era filled with extraordinary fighters, but I'd put him in the mythical p4p ring with ANY boxer...

[The Hammer]

Looks like most people rank him between 21-50.

[FeFist]

I'd place him in the second or third tier.

[onetwopunch]

I have him somewhere between 21-50, I mean I dont think he would of beat a prime DLH or a Prime Bazooka Ike or Tito, Shane or a prime Chavez, Wilfredo Benitez. There are alot of fighters that I have seen that Mayweather would not be able to beat. When he fought DLH and I saw how close the fight was I said to myself damn..Imagine if that was DLH in 1999..So Floyd is currently the best p4p boxer out there right now, but I think the fighters of past were just better.