From 140-154 who would you favor over Floyd?

[Weebler I]

it's become quite clear that cotto was the best 154 had to offer. that cotto was seen as having little chance was not floyd's problem. he's the best in the division above floyd's natural weight class.

and if you saw the fight, cotto did some good things in there. a very good fighter lost to a great fighter.

for the most part he fights top fighters, the divisions just arent that good. when WW was very hot floyd was semi retired. now it's pretty bleak.

Do you really believe that? look at Cotto's 154lb run - injured Foreman who was average anyway, a shot Mayorga and shot Margarito at 152lbs.

If Cotto is the really best 154lbs has to offer, shouldn't he have to prove it before being given the label?

[PAC-BOY]

Other than MANNY....JCCjr beats Floyd and Sergio @ 154! Canelo Alvarez beats him at 154 and 147 if he could make it! Broner would beat his azz too! @ 147.
Floyd will never fight any of these guys though! To dangerous. Bradley has a shot @ 140! He will probably fight Hatton again though!

[Larry the boss]

Other than MANNY....JCCjr beats Floyd and Sergio @ 154! Canelo Alvarez beats him at 154 and 147 if he could make it! Broner would beat his azz too! @ 147.
Floyd will never fight any of these guys though! To dangerous. Bradley has a shot @ 140! He will probably fight Hatton again though!

Lol Jr can barely make 160 how the hell can he make 154 without diuretics?and you would pick Canelo over Floyd or are you just trolling?

[285Kid]

2007 Welterweight, FLoyd Mayweather was the division main champion

Miguel Cotto
Paul Williams
Shane Mosley
Antonio Margarito
Vernon Forrest
Kermit Cintron
Luis Collazo
Joshua Clottey
Ike Quartey
Oktay Urkal

I wanted to see him in the ring with 5 of the men from that list, not the people they have now at 147

[Reloaded]

I guess you missed where he made JMM jump two divisions to fight him in his backyard and still took two extra pounds.

Imagine a prime RJJ, Toney or Benn asking FMJ to jump two divisions to 160 for the first time. Who you think wins? that's how ridiculous the Marquez fight was.



I don't think Floyd's cut out to fight genuine 154lb fighters. I know he beat a past prime Cotto there but MC was another fighter only stepping up, the fact Floyd was asking for a catchweight for any bout with Martinez should tell you something.

You talking about Manny and everything applies , the twist is Manny REFUSES to fight the weight versions that Floyd did , and you bag Floyd and defend Manny ,,,,, just a prime ****head !

[El Angel]

Do you really believe that? look at Cotto's 154lb run - injured Foreman who was average anyway, a shot Mayorga and shot Margarito at 152lbs.

If Cotto is the really best 154lbs has to offer, shouldn't he have to prove it before being given the label?

Who else at 154 could beat him? Lara and Canelo have the best chance, but Cotto would be the favorite over both for good reason.

[Larry the boss]

2007 Welterweight, FLoyd Mayweather was the division main champion

Miguel Cotto
Paul Williams
Shane Mosley
Antonio Margarito
Vernon Forrest
Kermit Cintron
Luis Collazo
Joshua Clottey
Ike Quartey
Oktay Urkal

I wanted to see him in the ring with 5 of the men from that list, not the people they have now at 147

i said NOW man..can you read?

[sammiza567]

bradley anyone? south of 168 bradley is the only one who i could see putting a gameplan together to outwork floyd but this is in 2 to 3 years when floyd has slowed down more. i'd still pick floyd but im just saying the only one south of 160 who i could even fathom having any chance is bradley. you have to outwork and out throw this guy and be tough enough to take the counter shots and keep pressing.

[Larry the boss]

bradley anyone? south of 168 bradley is the only one who i could see putting a gameplan together to outwork floyd but this is in 2 to 3 years when floyd has slowed down more. i'd still pick floyd but im just saying the only one south of 160 who i could even fathom having any chance is bradley. you have to outwork and out throw this guy and be tough enough to take the counter shots and keep pressing.

So Bradley when Floyd is damn near 40?

[Kagami Taiga]

the simple answer is no1. the ppl who try to argue dumb points just dint wanna say it. I mean jmm at 140? wtf? jmm could never beat Floyd at any weight.