Mayweather/Castillio 1 or Pacquiao/JMM 3, which fight was closer?

[cixthree]

Vote please

[Larry the boss]

Well Floyd won a comfortable ud in his first fight at 135 against a big lw.....Manny won a split decision against a 38 year old lightweight who had won 0 fights at ww

[TX_BOXNG]

moneymay vs castillo, pac vs jmm i had it 8-4

[Boxing Bob]

all 3 of the Pac/JMM fights were closer than Floyd/Cotto

[jayjames616]

I voted mayweather vs castillio. This fight was very close in my eyes and could have went either way. The Manny vs JMM fight was a clear JMM win.

[SCEN3RY]

and so begins the battle of the alts

oddly asked though, I mean I admit I scrutinized pac vs jmm 3 A LOT more carefully because of the backlash in terms of the magnitude of the fight, but I found a clear winner in both bouts...I'm actually glad you asked this, I think I owe mayweather-castillo more viewing. (I voted mayweather-castillo btw...I basically had it like a round closer)

[zcm]

If the mayweather/Castillo fight was scored 7/5 either way I wouldnt have argued with the scoring, but I felt Marquez won the PAC fight 7/5 at the worst (I had it 8/4).

[GrandpaBernard]

May-Castillo

Juan gave pacquiao a boxing lesson in their trilogy

[josenoway]

jlc-fmj 1.

[ADP02]

Well Floyd won a comfortable ud in his first fight at 135 against a big lw.....Manny won a split decision against a 38 year old lightweight who had won 0 fights at ww

You are quick to point out that Marquez hadn't won at WW .... that is kind of a weird statement coming from a Floyd fan.

At least Manny vs Marquez had a rivalry, what's Floyd's excuse for taking on these fighters?


Floyd fought at WW:
Marquez who had 0 fights at WW

Hatton who had 1 recent fight at WW but went back down for 2 after that performance .....hmmm..... lol

Ortiz who had 1 fight at WW and went life and death .... has a 1-2 record at WW now.

Sharmba who had 1 fight at WW ......

Khan who had 0 fights at WW but was supposed to be Floyd's next fight but a JWW changed that.

Judah who lost frequently at WW, including the fight prior to Floyd's against a very average fighter (Baldomir) and who finally decided that he doesn't belong at WW and went back down to 140!