Is Oscar De La Hoya a ATG??and if so where does he rank?

[crold1]

I see. Yeah, ATG is more like top 50 to me. Maybe 75 but that's pushing it. Oscar is near the bottom in top 100. So I could see how he's an ATG to you but not to me.

I think it comes down to ranges. There are, to me, levels of ATGness. Lopez is an ATG Strawweight but I don't think he rates as well across the scale. There are more than 100 fighters who can fit the bill depending on how individual division dominance is measured etc. Oscar wasn't an ATG in any one weight class and was just really good when he got to his prime weight class (Welter). His fame makes him a kind of ATG but, in the ring, I think he had some front runner to him and mediocre adaptability.