who's higher on your ATG list? Mayweather or Hopkins

[boliodogs]

This question is a joke, and shame on whoever is picking bhop.

Hopkins lost to Taylor twice, lost to Dawson, lost to Calzage

Floyd is undefeated and champion in 5 weight classes...

Hopkins signature win is vs a bloated Oscar and tito, a weight drained tarver and pascal..

Who did he beat in his 20 fight middle weight run? Joppy and Eastman were his biggest name? Get real

Being undefeated means nothing I see..

Hopkins lost to Taylor, Dawson, and Calzaghe when he was well past 40. If Floyd fights guys of that quality when he is well past 40 he will lose also. He ducked nobody at 160 over ten years and 20 defenses so you say there were all nothng special? You should get real. Being undefeated is not nearly as important as what a fighter did. Robinson lost 19 times and look at the respect he gets. Shame on you for not letting other posters pick Hopkins. They are both great.

[SkillspayBills]

Not even a debate, Floyd is the greastest fighter of his generation, top 5 most gifted fighters ever and already to 25-15 ATG.

[SCtrojansbaby]

so u honestly believe hopkins fought a prime winky at his prime weight class?

Winky was in his absolute prime anybody who argues that has no freaking idea what they are talking about.

at his prime weight class?

Obviously 170 isn't Winky's prime weight.

[CubanGuyNYC]

No surprise the poll is almost dead even. I think an effective argument can be made for either man, but I gave the nod to Floyd. And Mayweather might very well retire undefeated. Like it or not, that'll add an aura of invincibility that fans will argue about forever.

[IMDAZED]

Winky was in his absolute prime anybody who argues that has no freaking idea what they are talking about.



Obviously 170 isn't Winky's prime weight.

In his prime?

[timboslice708]

This question is a joke, and shame on whoever is picking bhop.

Hopkins lost to Taylor twice, lost to Dawson, lost to Calzage

Floyd is undefeated and champion in 5 weight classes...

Hopkins signature win is vs a bloated Oscar and tito, a weight drained tarver and pascal..

Who did he beat in his 20 fight middle weight run? Joppy and Eastman were his biggest name? Get real

Being undefeated means nothing I see..

I actually think Hopkins beat Taylor twice, and beat Calzhage. Did you even watch those fights?

[New England]

Winky was in his absolute prime anybody who argues that has no freaking idea what they are talking about.



Obviously 170 isn't Winky's prime weight.

so you're the only person who knows what he's talking about, and everybody else is wrong?

winky wright was not in his prime when he fought bernard hopkins.

[ИATAS]

why even argue over stinky wright, as if that means anything in regards to who is higher on the ATG list. Winky was just a win for bhop, nothing more. Matters nothing, really.

[SCtrojansbaby]

so you're the only person who knows what he's talking about, and everybody else is wrong?

winky wright was not in his prime when he fought bernard hopkins.

lol so in your opinion when was his prime in your opinion?

[SCtrojansbaby]

why even argue over stinky wright, as if that means anything in regards to who is higher on the ATG list. Winky was just a win for bhop, nothing more. Matters nothing, really.

B-Hop's win over Winky>any win Floyd has