Who's resume is better at 147lbs? Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[Atreyu Khalil]

Floyds resume at 147

Sharmba Mitchell KO
Zab Judah UD
Carlos Baldomir UD
Ricky Hatton KO
Juan Manuel Marquez UD
Shane Mosley UD
Victor Ortiz KO

Mannys resume at 147

Oscar De La Hoya KO
Miguel Cotto KO
Joshua Clottey UD
Shane Mosley UD
Juan Manuel Marquez UD
Timothy Bradley L

Keep in mind Floyd has beat the #1 ranked WW twice and Manny has never defeated a #1 ranked WW and his only win vs a champ at WW was at a catchweight. Considering where these fighters were ranked @WW,on the P4P list and the physical level they were at when Floyd and Manny fought them who's resume is better?

[Kagami Taiga]

its about even, imo.

[Atreyu Khalil]

its about even, imo.

De la hoya drained, Cotto at catch weight, clottey coming off a loss, mosley coming off a loss and a draw, getting beat by jmm....that's not even IMHO

[daggum]

strange how floyd fought baldomir(journeyman) and mosley(shot) when they were ranked #1 but not cotto, margarito or pac who were prime when they were ranked #1. It's almost as if he waited for some longshot to score an upset win then he pounced. He sure has great timing doesn't he!

[SugarAnt05]

Def Floyd. He beat them at comfortable weight. PAC still a monster though

[Mr. Fantastic]

De la hoya drained, Cotto at catch weight, clottey coming off a loss, mosley coming off a loss and a draw, getting beat by jmm....that's not even IMHO

JMM coming up two weight divisions and Floyd didn't fulfill the catchweight, Mitchell sucks, Zab coming off a loss, Hatton a 140 pounder, Mosley inactive for over 14+ months, Baldomir one of the worst Ring belt champs ever, Ortiz is a mental midget.

See it can go both ways. Just whatever you want to believe.

[Atreyu Khalil]

strange how floyd fought baldomir(journeyman) and mosley(shot) when they were ranked #1 but not cotto, margarito or pac who were prime when they were ranked #1. It's almost as if he waited for some longshot to score an upset win then he pounced. He sure has great timing doesn't he!

When Floyd fought Baldomir wasn't Cotto still at 140?

Shane was shot? He was coming off a destruction of margarito and was ranked #1 at ww and #3 p4p

[daggum]

When Floyd fought Baldomir wasn't Cotto still at 140?

Shane was shot? He was coming off a destruction of margarito and was ranked #1 at ww and #3 p4p

margarito was ranked #1. floyd didn't fight him.
cotto was ranked #1. floyd didn't fight him.
pac was ranked #1. floyd didn't fight him.
baldomir becomes #1. floyd fights him!
do the math.

and yes mosley was shot. did you see the fight? he had nothing and pac beat him just as easily a year later. did he suddenly turn shot after the mayweather fight even though he looked crap in it?

[Mr. Fantastic]

margarito was ranked #1. floyd didn't fight him.
cotto was ranked #1. floyd didn't fight him.
pac was ranked #1. floyd didn't fight him.
baldomir becomes #1. floyd fights him!
do the math.

and yes mosley was shot. did you see the fight? he had nothing and pac beat him just as easily a year later. did he suddenly turn shot after the mayweather fight even though he looked crap in it?

I find that funny as well. Mosley goes from top of the world when he fights Floyd and then to bum status when Pac fights him. Cotto goes from washed up to a serious threat when Floyd fought him. Floyd fanatics are pathetic.

[UnicornGirl]

It's a toss up.

Overall in all divisions, Floyd is the greater fighter, but Manny obviously got the better resume.
The fact that the op made a 'who's is better at 147' instead of 'overall resume' thread means he knows it as well.