How would Pacquiao do against Oscar's resume?

[CarlosG815]

Pac would not have fared well at all against the opposition that DLH faced.

[Khalid X]

First of all there is no way the Hopkins and Sturm fights happen as there is no way Manny would/could ever fight at MW.

Other than that.....the only person on Oscar's resume I see as tough fights for Manny are the Trinidad fight at 147 and Floyd fight.


He UD's both but in very tough competitive fights.

[boliodogs]

He loses against Pernell.
He loses against Trinidad.
He loses against Hopkins.
He loses against Mosley.
He loses against Strum.
He loses against Mayweather.

I also feel that Quartey and Vargas would beat him.

It is not a fair comparison as the guys who De La Hoya fought are decent sized welterweights and were in their prime. If they were still around today Pacquiao would be fighting at 140lbs.

It isn't a fair comparison. Oscar was a big welterweight and I think Pacquiao could still fight well at 135 if he choose to. He effortlessly made 138 for Hatton 3 years ago at age 30. You don't grow after age 30.He fights at 147 because that's where the money is and he can easily make weight without drying out.

[Pad83]

He'd only fight them after somebody else destroyed them.

Had to be said.