Better ww resume Manny or Cotto?

[whirlwind]

Only good W Manny have in WW is Cotto. The other fights are jokes. Cotto W over Shane is better than Oscar's and Clottey combine.

Well sure Cotto resume at welterweight is better than Pac but Pac beating Cotto is better than Cotto beating Mosley plus Pac beating Clottey in one sided fashion is also better than Cotto beating Clottey in a close fight. Not to mention this former flyweight knocked down Mosley and made him ran for his life.

[Bermuda]

the shane that manny beat < the shane that cotto beat

beat a younger shane who was coming off some wins where as pac fought a shane who was much older and had just come off a draw against mora and a loss to floyd...

cotto > judah

coming off a couple of losses to floyd and baldomir where as cotto was coming off a couple of wins against jennings and a close win against clottey...

clottey that pac beat > clottey that cotto beat

pac beat clottey much more decisively where as cotto struggled..

bradley > quintana

bradley was regarded as one of the best at 140 (if not the best) and although quintana would go on to later beat paul williams he didn't do much after that..

[WESS]

The fact that Cotto beat Mosley WHEN he did puts him at having a better WW resume IMO..

Pac's only fight worth mentioning at WW is vs Cotto and that was at a CW...

[kill the body]

Well sure Cotto resume at welterweight is better than Pac but Pac beating Cotto is better than Cotto beating Mosley plus Pac beating Clottey in one sided fashion is also better than Cotto beating Clottey in a close fight. Not to mention this former flyweight knocked down Mosley and made him ran for his life.

True but that Shane had just drew on Friday night fight with Sergio Mora

[El Angel]

Cotto edges him. His wins over Mosley, Judah, Quintana, Urkal, Clottey, Gomez, and Jennings are better than Manny's wins over De La Hoya, Cotto, Clottey, and Mosley. Marquez III was at CW and I'm giving him credit for what I saw as a clear win over Bradley.