how come james toney has always been fat?

[Sam Donald]

Genetics, no ones body is the same, he had obviously great fitness seeing as he could go a full 12 rounds with no problems so what does it matter ?.

hey man that's very true

[Jack Napier]

he likes to eat and doesn't train like he should
his skills were always enough to overcome that in his prime
past it, it started catching up to him
now he's flat out shot, so even if he's in shape it doesn't matter

[shogunn]

He likely ate like **** but still trained alot. Who knows what kinda meal plan he was on. We all know he liked burger king