What is your top 5 (or 10) pound for pound list looking like right now?

[johnm is...]

I don't have any problem with moving Manny down a few spots. But what I find funny, is the people justifying it by saying "like it or not, you have to move him down, because he has a loss to Bradley on the record".

Then those same people have Marquez at 2. I thought Marquez beat Pacquiao, but, like it or not, it's an "L" on his record.

Same rules don't apply, I guess.

[Primera]

I don't have any problem with moving Manny down a few spots. But what I find funny, is the people justifying it by saying "like it or not, you have to move him down, because he has a loss to Bradley on the record".

Then those same people have Marquez at 2. I thought Marquez beat Pacquiao, but, like it or not, it's an "L" on his record.

Same rules don't apply, I guess.

I think there's been a total of 1 person who's said that.

It's not because of his technical "loss" to Bradley, it's because of the fact that he's clearly on the decline. He couldn't even hurt a one legged Bradley, got taken to school by Marquez, and looked like an amateur against Oldsley.

[mexiking]

I think there's been a total of 1 person who's said that.

It's not because of his technical "loss" to Bradley, it's because of the fact that he's clearly on the decline. He couldn't even hurt a one legged Bradley, got taken to school by Marquez, and looked like an amateur against Oldsley.

I agree with said above.

[techliam]

well manny did lose 2 fights in a row imo

Manny dominated Bradley, how can Bradley be higher? Unless your criteria of p4p greats includes gift decisions, I dont see how you can justify that

[johnm is...]

I think there's been a total of 1 person who's said that.

It's not because of his technical "loss" to Bradley, it's because of the fact that he's clearly on the decline. He couldn't even hurt a one legged Bradley, got taken to school by Marquez, and looked like an amateur against Oldsley.

I don't know how many people said it in this thread. I didn't read the entire thread. But it's been said repeatedly since the fight. Believe it or not, this thread has been done a few times *gasp*.

And if it's not because of his loss to Bradley, then why weren't people moving him down after the Mosley fight?

[mexiking]

Manny dominated Bradley, how can Bradley be higher? Unless your criteria of p4p greats includes gift decisions, I dont see how you can justify that

Beat yes,dominated no!

[Primera]

They did move him down. Floyd moved up

[johnm is...]

They did move him down. Floyd moved up

LOL. Most had Floyd there already.

[RichCCFC]

How can people put Marquez above Pac?

Even if you thought he beat him, Pac has won more titles in more divisions and beat guys Marquez wouldn't.. such as Cotto.. Clottey.. even Margarito would probably beat him on size alone.

[Primera]

Damn even Boxrec moved Pac down to #5