My Biggest Disappointments This Year

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • vB Martin
    The Martinator
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Sep 2004
    • 1744
    • 131
    • 21
    • 8,177

    #1

    My Biggest Disappointments This Year

    1. The lackluster performances put in by Taylor against Hopkins both times.

      Yes, Hopkins has shown himself to be a master of the game for the past few years with good defense and knowing how to foul when the ref is blocked, but Taylor is a young, strong fighter who has shown aggressiveness and major skills in his previous matches.

      Yes, the detractors can say that he was fighting blown up Junior Middleweights and past-their-prime fighters, but Hopkins' signature win was against one who was a past-his-prime blown up lightweight, so that definitely evens the keel there.

      Taylor may go on to show us greatness. His slim and disputed victories against Hopkins may be completely attributed to Hopkins' defensive mastery and equally lackluster performance, but I expected more from the young guy who has been touted as the future of the Middleweight Division.
    2. The shellacking taken by Jameel McCline against Zuri Lawrence.

      First, McCline probably never reall belonged at the top of the heavyweight division, but he was there, and he damned near took out Chris Byrd. He showed flashes of possibility in that fight, and I have always hoped he would find that killer instinct in himself that would make him a complete and deadly fighter.

      For a man who walks around at 270+ lbs, he has shown stunning handspeed and pretty good stamina. He could have been someone had he found a way to make himself fight.

      Against Lawrence, someone not even worthy of being called a Journeyman, he lost almost every single round due due largely to being outworked. His heart wasn't in it.

      Do us a favor, Jameel. You seem to be one hell of a nice guy, and you have gone farther in boxing than perhaps you should have. If you can't find it in yourself to fight, don't. Use the nice guy image you have built and put it to good work talking to kids. There's always a place for ex-boxers from the tough streets to talk at schools.
    3. Robert Guerrero losing against Gamaliel Diaz.

      I don't want to take anything away from Diaz. He fought a great fight, consistently aggressive, poking holes in a defense that others could not find, and he won an impressive victory when he was just supposed to be an Opponent. Kudos to Diaz.

      For Guerrero's part, he looked out of sync the entire fight. It's the first time I've seen him in against a relentless opponent and he failed the test. I had high hopes of seeing him climb in weight and becoming a dominant champion at lightweight in a few years. He definitely has skills, and I hope he took something away from this fight that will allow him to learn and grow as a fighter.
    4. JCC, Jr, period.

      Ok, we get it. You're the som of a legend, and you show some skill, but it's time for you to step up in competition or get out of the game. I can no longer get excited seeing you, with 23 wins now, fighting club fighters. Either fight someone at least considered a Journeyman or quit wasting our time.
    5. James Toney vs. John Ruiz

      I had great hopes that Toney would finally end the attempts of the WWE to infiltrate boxing at its highest level, but my hopes were shot to hell with the positive steroid test.

      Yes, James, we understand that you had a prescription to heal the muscles you tore in your fight against Booker, but it would seem that if they were the same steroids found in your system, you wouldn't have had the belts stripped. Thanks for screwing up our chance to get rid of Ruiz. Now, thanks to you, we face the possibility of Ruiz being replaced by yet another freakshow.
    6. Castillo vs Corrales (X 2)

      The first fight was one for the ages. Brutal, non-stop action from beginning to end, only to be ruined by Castillo's whining after the fight about the mouthpiece issue.

      Face it, Jose. If you had had him truly hurt, there is no way he would have gotten off the canvas and beat you along the ropes like a ragdoll. I understand your pride, but you were out. You were out because you got complacent and let one of the hardest puchers in your division tag you good. The 15 extra seconds could not account for his ability to end you like that if he was ever truly hurt.

      And how to you respond to it? By coming in overweight for the second fight. Again, you let your pride screw you up in the eyes of many. You have tainted yourself as a fighter by refusing to make a contracted weight. Yes, I'm aware that he came in the ring at roughly the same weight, but he, unlike you, had to drain himself to make weight. Your stunning KO will always have that asterisk beside it now. You really accomplished nothing by cheating the way you did.
    7. Mike Tyson vs. Kevin McBride

      Mike, to be honest, I had no hope that a stunning victory against McBride would vault you back into the heavyweight picture. I did, however, hope that someone with a legendary, though marred, career such as yours could go out on a winning note. Please, for all of us, stay on the canvas this time. There are those of us who, despite your sometimes bizarre behavior, choose to remember you as you were. Allow us that.
    8. The Return of Rid**** Bowe

      We love you Rid****, even though you are perhaps the biggest waste of raw talent to ever hit the heavyweight division. Despite what you think, your brain is no longer functioning at full capacity. If it were, you would realize it wasn't. You were a great fighter but you weren't all that bright to being with. Please don't make it worse.
    Add your own if you like.
  • !! Anorak
    • Aug 2025
    • 4,530
    • 10,899
    • 0

    #2
    What about the threat of seeing Klitschko close Rahman's mouth, only to be constantly put back and then the potential for division unification retire?

    Also, the realisation that Roy Jones just came back with the intention of staying upright.

    Comment

    • vB Martin
      The Martinator
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Sep 2004
      • 1744
      • 131
      • 21
      • 8,177

      #3
      Valid points, but the Klits and RJJ rarely interest me enough to sta in my memory.

      Comment

      • Kimmy
        Umpalumpa Police
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Mar 2004
        • 3246
        • 168
        • 63
        • 10,090

        #4
        Yes, the Roy Jones situation was quite sad. Consider also Felix Trinidad. I am not a fan of him but i do feel sorry for him. Out of all the substandard middleweights in the world Tito has to face Winky Wright. If an old Bernard Hopkins can shut out Tito, what was Don King thinking matching Tito with a Winky Wright in the prime of his career.
        ****** MOVE!!!

        Comment

        • vB Martin
          The Martinator
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Sep 2004
          • 1744
          • 131
          • 21
          • 8,177

          #5
          Yeah. I completely forgot that one. I loved Tito, but I always knew he was a one-dimensional fighter. If he decides to come out of retirement again, I hope it's without Papa Trinidad in his corner.

          Comment

          • Kimmy
            Umpalumpa Police
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Mar 2004
            • 3246
            • 168
            • 63
            • 10,090

            #6
            Originally posted by vB Martin
            Yeah. I completely forgot that one. I loved Tito, but I always knew he was a one-dimensional fighter. If he decides to come out of retirement again, I hope it's without Papa Trinidad in his corner.
            Agreed, and i also hope for his sake that its without a prime southpaw with a good chin in the other corner!!

            Comment

            • Meester Keester
              Banned
              Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
              • Dec 2005
              • 164
              • 18
              • 13
              • 249

              #7
              Originally posted by vB Martin
              [list=1][*]JCC, Jr, period.

              Ok, we get it. You're the som of a legend, and you show some skill, but it's time for you to step up in competition or get out of the game. I can no longer get excited seeing you, with 23 wins now, fighting club fighters. Either fight someone at least considered a Journeyman or quit wasting our time.
              I understand where you are coming from but at the same time I have to disagree with you. Jr. had no amateur career at all, so these early fights are essentially his learning period. Of course he was more advanced having Sr. as his dad, but he still had no experience to speak of.

              What my problem is the coverage he's been getting, not the fact he's still fighting turds in his 25th fight. I always figured he'd be on of those guys that finally fought for a title around his 45th fight or so. He seems to currently be on that pace.

              It's the fault of the people putting him on ppv's and such. He shouldn't be getting so much exposure so soon.

              Comment

              • Pac Man Fan 83
                Mayweather: P4P King
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jun 2005
                • 2067
                • 114
                • 158
                • 8,811

                #8
                Originally posted by vB Martin
                [list=1][*]The lackluster performances put in by Taylor against Hopkins both times.

                Yes, Hopkins has shown himself to be a master of the game for the past few years with good defense and knowing how to foul when the ref is blocked, but Taylor is a young, strong fighter who has shown aggressiveness and major skills in his previous matches.

                Yes, the detractors can say that he was fighting blown up Junior Middleweights and past-their-prime fighters, but Hopkins' signature win was against one who was a past-his-prime blown up lightweight, so that definitely evens the keel there.

                Taylor may go on to show us greatness. His slim and disputed victories against Hopkins may be completely attributed to Hopkins' defensive mastery and equally lackluster performance, but I expected more from the young guy who has been touted as the future of the Middleweight Division.
                Trying out for a writing job for boxingscene?

                Comment

                • vB Martin
                  The Martinator
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Sep 2004
                  • 1744
                  • 131
                  • 21
                  • 8,177

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Tito Fan 83
                  Trying out for a writing job for boxingscene?
                  Nope. Not biased enough to even hope for that

                  Comment

                  • Super_Lightweight
                    Jesus of Nazareth P4P
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Jan 2005
                    • 7746
                    • 452
                    • 556
                    • 15,482

                    #10
                    hmm

                    It's ****** to say Chico's extra recovery time didn't help him win the fight. That's obviously false. And yes, Corrales was truly hurt. Castillo made a mistake by jumping on him, but had Chico not gotten the extra time, Castillo would have taken him out. Also, it was more than 15 seconds (as if that doesn't help).

                    JCC Jr has no amateur background, is young as hell, and does not need to step up his comp right now.

                    Also, it was dumb to expect and exciting fight between Taylor and Hops the second go round. That as an obvious "no-buy" ppv.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP