Toney vs Hop

[Grimgash]

Who wins this at Middle?

[Void]

James "Lights Out" Toney.

[TyrantT316]

tough one...both value defense (post Tito Hopkins went REALLY defensive)...

I think Hopkins overall would just be in better condition to do well over 12 close rounds...would be a lot of waiting...but I just don't see Toney countering Hopkins as easily as he does other fighters

[Kimmy]

I voted Toney but it really is a too close to call type of fight!

[-Jay-]

Could Toney even get down to 160Lbs?

[Easy-E]

Could Toney even get down to 160Lbs?

obv not now, this is when the were in their primes of their career, fighting at middleweight
bhop ud

[dino]

hopkins may win by UD if he runs around like he normally does..or toney would win by UD..either way this would be a boring fight...their styles match up for a boring fight

[Undefeated]

are u serious??? toney will murder hopkins....hopkins could even drop taylor what makes u think he gonna beat toney

[JUYJUY]

Toney for sure.

[whdempsey]

Toney. Toney, Toney, Toney. When Toney was at middleweight, and Hopkins was his mandatory, Hopkins was little more than a righ hand crazy kid. In other words: Toney's dream opponent. The fight at a catchweight that was being discussed a year or so ago would have been much more competitive.