Better resume.Sugar Ray Leaonard or Manny Pacqiuo

[Roman Moreno]

60lbs > 3lbs

Look at this ******ed logic, that case.

3lbs > 0lbs.

5lbs > 0lbs.

1lb > 0lbs

7lbs> 0lbs

According to D4 math, Oscar, Mosley, Cotto, Morales were all more weight-drained than Duran was.

So what is your argument again?

[rorymac]

I've got SRL around the 20 mark on my ATG list.

Pacquiao is higher.

Pac wouldn't touch my top 80 I don't think. Credit for having SRL at 20 though. I'd have him about 16-25 as well.

[Roman Moreno]

I've got SRL around the 20 mark on my ATG list.

That's fine, and it sounds about right, sure why not.

Pacquiao is higher.

Which proves again how ******ed you are.

[D4thincarnation]

Pac wouldn't touch my top 80 I don't think. Credit for having SRL at 20 though. I'd have him about 16-25 as well.

People tend to rate past fighters higher, Ali was not held in the same regard when he was active as he is now.

And even back then people were saying boxing is dying.


As Joni Mitchel said, "You don't know what you've got till it's gone"

[D4thincarnation]

This is a redundant point mate, it's a completely different idea. When you're starting around Bantam, it's easier to move up because the distance between each weight class is much smaller. So you're saying, for Leonard to be considered better than Pac, he should have gained 60lbs while Pac gained about 35??

Do it as percentage of body mass to make it fair.

Pacquiao 106 lbs to 154lbs, whats that about 49%

Leonard 147 lbs to 175lbs about 20%

[rorymac]

People tend to rate past fighters higher, Ali was not held in the same regard when he was active as he is now.

And even back then people were saying boxing is dying.


As Joni Mitchel said, "You don't know what you've got till it's gone"

I rate past fighters higher because they were more experienced and mentally tougher. They fought every top contender during their era so they couldn't hide their flaws like the fighters of today.

The guy in your avatar is my number 1 or 2.

[rorymac]

Do it as percentage of body mass to make it fair.

Pacquiao 106 lbs to 154lbs, whats that about 49%

Leonard 147 lbs to 175lbs about 20%

Sorry to say it guv but this is the single most biased post I've ever seen. The heaviest Pacquiao has ever been was 145.5 against Clottey. You said in your earlier post that it would be the equivalent of SRL going to HEAVYWEIGHT. That's 200lbs or more.

Obviously I considered the idea of weight percentage, just calculated the result based on the rules you stated

[Alx.]

it's not even close leonard

[D4thincarnation]

Sorry to say it guv but this is the single most biased post I've ever seen. The heaviest Pacquiao has ever been was 145.5 against Clottey. You said in your earlier post that it would be the equivalent of SRL going to HEAVYWEIGHT. That's 200lbs or more.

Obviously I considered the idea of weight percentage, just calculated the result based on the rules you stated

Leonard was 165lbs agaisnt Lalonde too, but I took the light-heavy limit for my stat.

If I were to do it your weight Pacquiao's edge would be greater still.

[Barry Halls]

Floyd vs Sweet Pea

There's some zingers in there from Larry. Packed with lulz.

The biggest "lulz" is that 40+ % of the voters picked Floyd to have the better resume.

In this thread the ******o% is only ~16.