Who is most likely to give Mayweather his first defeat?

[TheEvilSaint]

guess you didn't notice Judah and Spinks getting their feet tangled as Judah was pulling away, but it's cool

i saw the 1st fight the night it was on but that was the only time i saw it.

so yeah, i probly missed that.

[Kayo]

EA Sports Fight Night Round III

[RiverCityMike]

I said Hatton, but in truth, I think that Mayweather will never even fight Hatton. They'll offer him **** money, so he'll refuse and then say he's the one who's afraid. Floyd's hands won't allow him to fight a guy like Hatton. The closest he's gone to that is Castillo, but he's a plodder and still won the first fight in my opinion. Hatton will flatten him. He'll fight Judah instead, whose chin is precious as a pane at Chartres and the common man (at least in America) will still believe it was the better match up.

[Mech.]

I picked hatton.Although i believe Marg has a chance because of his size.The reason i went with hatton is because if your gonna go all out to really try to beat Mayweather,you have to go after him non-stop since your unlikely to outbox him.

[jsims2]

I suppose if we're assuming that PBF will actually FIGHT any of these guys I would have to go with Hatton on this list, but overall I don't think he could beat Wright. Personally, I think PBF will dance around guys like Zab and Hatton his entire career and retire without fighting anyone of real substance.

[Moon]

I want to see Hatton-PBF first, just to get things settled.

If (there's always if) PBF prevails, which he should, then it's Floyd's turn to fall at either the hands of Judah or Margarito. Both guys have heavier hands than anyone who has landed on Floyd, and they will land. Sure Judah's chin will always be questioned, but he offers PBF a serious challenge, what with his reflexes and boxing skills, coupled with the power. Margarito is an animal and would give PBF fits with his natural size and ease at this weight, coupled with a granite chin that let's him get closer than Floyd would like.

[Brockton Lip]

Margarito or Judah.

[RiverCityMike]

Quote me on this: I don't think Mayweather will ever fight Hatton. I think that Judah's chin is glass and that'll be proven. I think that Margarito is just another Castillo to Mayweather (you could maybe through Cotto in here too). Ha, the plodding latinos, but it is still the bare truth. Hatton or nobody but Wright, but even if he gets balls enough to fight Winky, he'll still dodge hatton.

[Manny_P]

Zab Judah is most likely to beat Floyd. Judah has the speed, the skills and the power to give Mayweatha a surpring first loss. Mayweath is fightin on a weight class he shoulnt be in IMO. 147lbs is Judah's turf. He's gonna have problems wit Judah win or lose. The mo I think bout tis, the mo I'm favorin Judah to win.

[STEELHEAD]

its unreal to think mayweather would fight winky or margarito at 154.both would win.

mosley has a good chance. and i would hope zab would in a battle with flashes of fireworks.