Originally posted by VapeRippa
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker
Collapse
-
-
Originally posted by PBP View PostThe statement that Floyd beat more champions is incorrect. I even gave Floyd the benefit of the doubt and inclufrd NABF and NABO champions.
Champions defeated by Mayweather:
Hernandez
Jukko
Vargas
Corrales
Hernandez
Chavez
Castillo x 2
Corley
Bruseles
Judah
Baldo
Gatti
Mitchell
De La Hoya
Hatton
Marquez
Mosley
Ortiz
Cotto
Total: 20
Whitaker:
Mayweather
Ramirez x 2
Haugen
Pendleton
Nelson
Nazario
Chavez
Rivera x2
Hurtado
McGirt x 2
Cardona
Vazquez
Rodriguez
Jones
Pineda
Paez
Brazier
Total: 20
I'm going to check these othet statements tooOriginally posted by PBP View PostHere's p4 p victories. Only includes guys that were on the list when they faced them:
Floyd:
Marquez #3
Hatton #8
Corrales #5
Mosley #3
Whitaker:
Chavez #1
McGirt#5
Nelson #7
Take that how you want it
Comment
-
Originally posted by Light_Speed View PostThese facts don't scream "Pernell >>>>>>>> Floyd and you're a nuthugger if you think otherwise ROFL herp derp" seems to me they're neck and neck but if you take into account Floyd's consistency and achievements (# of weightclasses conquered, staying undefeated while doing so) you have a case for ranking him slightly higher than Pernell.
most ranking have Pernell ranked 10-15.so if he is up there then so is Floyd
Comment
-
Originally posted by Light_Speed View PostThese facts don't scream "Pernell >>>>>>>> Floyd and you're a nuthugger if you think otherwise ROFL herp derp" seems to me they're neck and neck but if you take into account Floyd's consistency and achievements (# of weightclasses he conquered, # of lineal champs he beat, staying undefeated while doing so) you have a case for ranking him slightly higher than Pernell.
Comment
-
Originally posted by bojangles1987 View PostOr you could take a look at the names on that list and see that Whitaker beat decisively better competition. Just something to throw out there.
Comment
-
-
its one thing to say floyd's resume is better than pernell. thats cool, say it and back it up. its when u start backing it up with ******ity that ppl wil start making fun of u.
Comment
-
Originally posted by larryx2013 View Postbetter comp based on what???cause we are listing the names and rankings at the time and im not seeing that at all
Comment
-
And by the way on paper sweet pea drew with Chavez so he only beat 19 champs to Floyd's 20. It'll probably be 22-23 by the time he retires.
Comment
Comment