Who beat Mosley more convincingly Cotto or Mayweather??

[Larry the boss]

mayweather but in cotto's defense he faced a 36 year old mosley who hadnt lost in his last 5 fights.

Mayweather on the other hand faced a 39 year old mosley coming off a 14 month layoff.

cotto also never got hit with the punch floyd took in round 2.

yes he did.all damn night

[ßringer]

This is such a mind-numbingly ****** question that I'm not even going to dignify it with a response. Instead, I'll just say "fuck you, TS."

[-PBP-]

Let me hijack this thread and replace Mosley with Judah. NOW we can have a real discussion.

[Optimistic]

Miguel beat a better version of Mosley in a close but clear fight.

Mayweather utterly dominated Shane.

****** thread.

[mozzer101]

Since watching it on HBO lately I started to think who beat Mosley more convincingly IMO it was cotto what do you guys think????

Is this a serious question? Watch the fights again im sure you will figure it out.

[NearHypnos]

The fact that there's people out there who think Shane beat Cotto should make this question not exist.

Floyd beat Shane worse than Pac did too imo. The Pac fight made Pac look just as awkward...Cotto's was a close and possibly disputed decision. When Floyd was hitting Shane it was sad as hell..shoulda been stopped it got real out of hand. Shane at one point looked like he was all "Come o...-punch- n stop hitt-punch-ing me -punch"

The way Shane got beat VS Floyd is the one thing people hate seeing happen to a fighter who stayed too late. The only worse thing that could happen is getting KOd by an unproven champion...and he is setting himself up for that one.

WAR SHANE! I still want him to KO Canelo. Even though i like Canelo...but I got some serious Shane bias.

[New England]

shane hurt floyd more seriously than he did cotto but if you're going by a legitimate scorecard then it's floyd by a landslide

cotto did backpedal a good deal at the end of the mosley fight, but floyd was on ***** street and buckling knees. he almost went down.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Since Cotto did nothing but run from Mosley from the 7th till the 12th,I'd say Mayweather by a mile...

[S IP U IR S xII]

neither...Vernon Forrest

[Carpe Diem]

Mosley could've won that fight if he knew how to set up the straight right hand better. He had Cotto cornered on the ropes, but he never took advantage of it.