who ranks higher judah or hatton?

[bojangles1987]

Ricky Hatton. He was the man at 140 and was P4P for awhile.

Judah was undisputed for two seconds and he's very inconsistent.

Yep. If Judah ever sat atop a division for any amount of time maybe this would be a discussion, but he never came close.

[boliodogs]

I think history will rank Hatton higher but I voted for Zab although it's close. I don't pay much attention to the Tszyu fights because he had gone downhill alot when Hatton fought him and the ref let Hatton get away with murder. Hatton has only 2 losses to Zab's 7 losses. Zab was a champion 4 years before Hatton and won a tittle after Hatton retired. He has more wins over better fighters and the quality of his opponents is better overall. If they fought with both in their prime I think Zab would catch him rushing in and KO him. Plus Judah is usually fun to watch and Hatton's style makes me sick so that influenced my vote.

[boliodogs]

I did not see my name in the results so I voted to late.

[MARKBNLV]

I would go with Judah prime vrs prime i just think he batters and stops Hatton,not to mention he was holding straps before Ricky and after him.

[D-MiZe]

Holding a belt before and after Hatton doesn't mean anything.

[CHOWWOKKA]

Why would you close the votes? Clearly the intelligent voters aren't up yet if Judah is still trailing..

[hugh grant]

hatton was better as he has only lost once to Pac. The floyd loss i dont count. Too much referee help for Floyd.

[MARKBNLV]

Holding a belt before and after Hatton doesn't mean anything.

Being a better fighter does,and Judah imo was more skilled and just plain better at his peak,the Tyszu Hatton fought wanted nothing to do with boxing by that point.

[thepower]

If fights only lasted 6 rounds, then it would be Zab. But they don't, so its Ricky.

[bdevils]

hatton was better as he has only lost once to Pac. The floyd loss i dont count. Too much referee help for Floyd.

Lmao, so that was the ref who check hooked his a$$ into the ring post?? You should really stop posting dude. Your love for Pac and hatred for Floyd is really disturbing!