Jermain Taylor vs. Chavez Jr. Who'd win?

[BattlingNelson]

So it looks like Taylor is coming back. I hope he is healthy enough and that the layoff has done him good.

He is looking to campaign at 160 again.

I sure'd like to see him beat Junior.

Who would win?

[BattlingNelson]

Taylor is washed up

Possible. Maybe even likely, but I personally don't Think Taylor has to be at 100% to beat Junior.

[Light_Speed]

Even this version of Taylor is leagues above Chavez Jr. His chin has been cracked but if scrubs like Matt Vanda and John Duddy can go the distance with Jr then Taylor certainly can and he would win a UD.

[ropeadope89]

Prime tylor ko's jr. Tylor right now? Jr. By decision.

[Ringlife]

Chavez Jr by Ko.

[talip bin osman]

interesting fight bat...

taylor's richer experience fighting the better guys gives him a significant edge here...

but then again, he might be quite shot at this point and JCC jr, if he becomes motivated and implements a good gameplan from roach could really win also...

[New England]

So it looks like Taylor is coming back. I hope he is healthy enough and that the layoff has done him good.

He is looking to campaign at 160 again.

I sure'd like to see him beat Junior.

Who would win?

oops, lol

i voted before i saw that you were talking about a realistic fight in the near future. i voted taylor, thinking it was going to be JT in his prime vs JR


i think chavez would probably win a decision now. maybe he'd stop taylor if he tires, but i tend do doubt it. taylor knows how to box and take care of himself enough to keep from getting knocked out by jr, even if he is very shot