Who has the better resume Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacquiao?

[tatangb45]

That was a real question.

OK, it's Mcgirt.

Now watch these videos and decide intelligently (if you are capable of doing that) who is better between the two.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2iqy4gOQZw

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08kUTlcjCfU

[Roman Moreno]

not at all. I thought Sweat Pea won the fight. I haven't seen that fight in years though.

Then Why would you even bring it up for?

That was one of the worse robberies of all time. Just because he was a SD loss, doesn't mean that Whitaker didn't dominate the fight.

Floyd Mayweather, had a SD win against Oscar. But, that fight wasn't close at all. You couldn't give Oscar more than 4 rounds and that is being generous. Floyd won clearly 8 rounds. Whitaker was much more dominant against Ramirez than what Floyd was against Oscar. Looking at boxred and seeing SD W/L doesn't necessary mean it was close at all.

Again one of the worse robberies of all time. It is hard for me to find a bigger robbery than that one in the last 30 years. Only Martinez-Cintron might challenge it just because he got robbed twice in the same fight. But, that's how big the robbery of the first Whitaker-Ramirez fight was.

[Roman Moreno]

OK, it's Mcgirt.

Now watch these videos and decide intelligently (if you are capable of doing that) who is better between the two.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2iqy4gOQZw

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08kUTlcjCfU

I looked, I saw, I concluded that it is/was Whitaker.

[catalinul]

Even Whitakers trainer was telling whitaker in the corner i believe before the 10th or 11th that "This is a close fight now, you gotta win these next few rounds" or something of the sorts.....why would he say that if he himself who trains whitaker and was watching the fight at ringside didn't feel it was close at all?

The same guy told Meldrick Taylor he needed the 12th round to beat Chavez.

Doesn't mean anything.

Scoring wise Whitaker won the fight going away.

[Atreyu Khalil]

The same guy told Meldrick Taylor he needed the 12th round to beat Chavez.

Doesn't mean anything.

Scoring wise Whitaker won the fight going away.

How does whitaker fair vs Henry Armstrong? Benny Leonard? Roberto Duran? @ 135lbs

[Atreyu Khalil]

I looked, I saw, I concluded that it is/was Whitaker.

He believes Pac is a better fighter than Whitaker?

[catalinul]

How does whitaker fair vs Henry Armstrong? Benny Leonard? Roberto Duran? @ 135lbs

Don't have enough knowledge to make a pick against Armstrong or Leonard.

I'd probably pick him against Duran.

[Atreyu Khalil]

Don't have enough knowledge to make a pick against Armstrong or Leonard.

I'd probably pick him against Duran.

One of my co-workers thinks a lightweight Shane Mosley would have gave Whitaker problems....

[catalinul]

I love Shane but.....

His lightweight run was good no doubt,maybe even very good but his opponents weren't exactly top notch.

[tatangb45]

I looked, I saw, I concluded that it is/was Whitaker.

Be more specific. Based on those two videos, in what department would you say Whitaker is better than Pac? Movement? Power? Accuracy? Work rate?

Let's try to be without bias, OK?