Who has the better resume Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacquiao?

[Atreyu Khalil]

Who beats him at 135-140?

I mean Jose Luis Ramirez beat him @135lbs....so there is no way "absolutely" is applicable in this case.

[catalinul]

Ramirez hardly ''beat him''.

[Roman Moreno]

I mean Jose Luis Ramirez beat him @135lbs....so there is no way "absolutely" is applicable in this case.

You watched that fight?

[Atreyu Khalil]

Ramirez hardly ''beat him''.

So close fights don't count as losses?
Fact is it was a SD and he lost so therefor if Ramirez was able to get a SD, then there are numerous fighters who would have been able to give him a run for his money at 135 & 140lbs.

Sweat Pea is one of my favorite fighters but to say absolutely no fighter ever in those weight classes beats him is absurd

[Atreyu Khalil]

You watched that fight?

Yes and I thought that Sweat Pea won the fight...

[catalinul]

So close fights don't count as losses?
Fact is it was a SD and he lost so therefor if Ramirez was able to get a SD, then there are numerous fighters who would have been able to give him a run for his money at 135 & 140lbs.

Sweat Pea is one of my favorite fighters but to say absolutely no fighter ever in those weight classes beats him is absurd

That wasn't close at all in my opinion.

I would go on a limb and say Whitaker pretty much dominated Ramirez twice only to get robbed once.

[Roman Moreno]

So close fights don't count as losses?
Fact is it was a SD and he lost so therefor if Ramirez was able to get a SD,

Yes and I thought that Sweat Pea won the fight...

And, you thought it was a close fight?

[Atreyu Khalil]

I agree, absolutely nobody

Henry Armstrong? Benny Leonard? Roberto Duran?....none of these guys could challenge Whitaker @135lbs?

[Atreyu Khalil]

And, you thought it was a close fight?

not at all. I thought Sweat Pea won the fight. I haven't seen that fight in years though.

[Atreyu Khalil]

That wasn't close at all in my opinion.

I would go on a limb and say Whitaker pretty much dominated Ramirez twice only to get robbed once.

Even Whitakers trainer was telling whitaker in the corner i believe before the 10th or 11th that "This is a close fight now, you gotta win these next few rounds" or something of the sorts.....why would he say that if he himself who trains whitaker and was watching the fight at ringside didn't feel it was close at all?