Who has the better resume Pernell Whitaker or Manny Pacquiao?

[h2k]

These are two of the best southpaws of all time!

pacman and it's not even close.

[COACH WEBB]

Only one of those really comparable is Homicide Hank. . . Lol it's still funny that just about every fight he had was contested at a catchweight.

But to the TS's question, Pac has the better resume. . . Pac is the best southpaw of all time. . . .

Morales TWICE, Mab TWICE, Marquez TWICE? Cotto? Hatton (at his natural weight). . . CLottey (who everybody seems to underrated for some reason - but seeing how Pac is the ONLY BOXER to EVER beat him so one-sidedly). . .

Not to mention his slew of other wins against world champs, and fringe world class guys.

How did I know Clottey would be discussed? SMH. Pathetic.

LOL is this a serious question considering Pac has probably a top ten all time resume?

[COACH WEBB]

The better way to judge and see who is better is to watch carefully their styles of fighting. Watch both videos below and decide.

This one is Pernell vs. Mcgirth l.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h2iqy4gOQZw

This next one is Pacquiao vs. Cotto
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=08kUTlcjCfU

Who is that?

[Atreyu Khalil]

Even though I respect Whittaker a ton, he is nowhere in the same galaxy resume-wise.

Please list his top ten wins and I will list Pacquiao's and we will debate.

In no special oprder:

1)Lehlo Ledwaba
2)Marco Antonio Barrera x2
3)Juan Manuel Marquez x2
4)Erik Morales x2
5)Jorge Solis
6)Oscar De La Hoya
7)Ricky Hatton
8)Miguel Cotto
9)Antonio Margarito
10)Shane Mosley

Ledwaba?? That dude is trash are you for real? Who the **** is Ledwaba?

The first Barrera win was good, the 2nd fight Barrera was 4 years later and MAB was already passed on the decline and just came off a loss to Juan Manuel Marquez.

Erik Morales? Pac got outboxed by a washed up Morales then only beat him after Zahir Raheem boxed his ears off.

Jorge Solis? who the **** is Jorge Solis?

De La hoya? fighting Oscar at a weight he didn't fight at in 8 years?? really?

Hatton? After Mayweather knocked him out?

Miguel Cotto? @ a catchweight after Cotto struggled with Joshua Clottey?

Antonio Margarito? The over rated bricked gloved cheater?

Shane Mosley? After he declined to fight Mosley when he was the #1 ranked WW? After Mosley came off 2 terrible fights vs Mayweather & Mora? After Bob Arum said Mosley was pretty much over the hill & old and didn't deserve a fight with Pac because he was an aging fighter?


Lets get real man

[Atreyu Khalil]

Who is that?

Buddy Mcgirth must be a **** star

[tatangb45]

Who is that?

Your best comeback?

[ussy]

It's not a knock on Pac but there isn't a fighter in history that anyone can say with certainty beats a prime Whitaker.

I agree, absolutely nobody

[Atreyu Khalil]

I agree, absolutely nobody

absolutely?

[COACH WEBB]

Your best comeback?

That was a real question.

[Roman Moreno]

absolutely?

Who beats him at 135-140?