Full Campillo/Cloud scorecards submitted by judges [Pic]

[-Kev-]

I gave 1, 4, 6 and 12 to Cloud. So that's 114-112 Campillo. That's about as far as you can go with Cloud, those 4 rounds. I have to admit though, watching the actual fight after reading the RBR discussions from my phone and seeing Cloud get bashed for his performance and compared to Calzaghe-Lacy, I thought it was really bad. I panicked in the fight after Cloud had won that 10-7 round, 4th round, and 6th round(on my scorecard) I'm like, hold on a second, this fight is gonna be closer than I thought, this ain't no Calzaghe-Lacy. In the late rounds there might have been 2 close rounds that could have been given to Cloud, but I only gave him one. The fact is, it was a great fight that was tarnished by that 116-110 scorecard.

If the judges really wanted to push it, they could have made it a draw. But they went overboard by giving the fight to Cloud.

[Salardo]

I gave 1, 4, 6 and 12 to Cloud. So that's 114-112 Campillo. That's about as far as you can go with Cloud, those 4 rounds. I have to admit though, watching the actual fight after reading the RBR discussions from my phone and seeing Cloud get bashed for his performance and compared to Calzaghe-Lacy, I thought it was really bad. I panicked in the fight after Cloud had won that 10-7 round, 4th round, and 6th round(on my scorecard) I'm like, hold on a second, this fight is gonna be closer than I thought, this ain't no Calzaghe-Lacy. In the late rounds there might have been 2 close rounds that could have been given to Cloud, but I only gave him one. The fact is, it was a great fight that was tarnished by that 116-110 scorecard.

If the judges really wanted to push it, they could have made it a draw. But they went overboard by giving the fight to Cloud.

I had even Cloud winning it by 2 points. dont know why everybody said Campillo was robbed bigtime. of course cloud was the one who looked like the loser with his injuries, but when I just score the rounds, I have him winning the fight closely.
actually this reminded me of Lucas Matthysse vs Devon Alexander: everybody was saying that was a disgraceful robbery and when i watched it, I had Matthysse winning by only 1 point. it was still a robbery, but ....

[vacon04]

I gave 1, 4, 6 and 12 to Cloud. So that's 114-112 Campillo. That's about as far as you can go with Cloud, those 4 rounds. I have to admit though, watching the actual fight after reading the RBR discussions from my phone and seeing Cloud get bashed for his performance and compared to Calzaghe-Lacy, I thought it was really bad. I panicked in the fight after Cloud had won that 10-7 round, 4th round, and 6th round(on my scorecard) I'm like, hold on a second, this fight is gonna be closer than I thought, this ain't no Calzaghe-Lacy. In the late rounds there might have been 2 close rounds that could have been given to Cloud, but I only gave him one. The fact is, it was a great fight that was tarnished by that 116-110 scorecard.

If the judges really wanted to push it, they could have made it a draw. But they went overboard by giving the fight to Cloud.

I had it exactly like that, and I don't see how could some judge give round #9 to Cloud, he was completely embarrassed by Campillo in round 9.

[jai mari078]

I had 115 - 111 Campillo. I could see 114 - 112 at the worst ! I don't know what Fuc*in fight Robertdon was watching 116 - 110!

This was a blatant robbery. I don't care how inexperienced a judge you are. It doesn't take a genious to see Campillo dominated Cloud after that first round!

[RlCKY]

Serious Question: What does it take to be a major fight judge?

Anyone, boxing fan or not, can sit there and watch that fight round by round and say ok Campillo won this round, Cloud won this round.

There are people on here, however few, who can respectfully say I believe that Cloud won, and that is fine. You're talking maybe a dozen of how many total posters. But to have 2 out of 3 judges who feel that way, its unfathomable.

[RobAK47]

I feel that campillo won, but it's no robbery because of the 2 K.D's Cloud scored that gave him 10-7 and that's great jump start to any fight.

[Brandish]

cloud won-- i gave him 1-4-6-9-11-12

campillo had a strong tenth but came out in the 11th and 12th and got outworked...he lost the fight on the last two rounds.

[vacon04]

cloud won-- i gave him 1-4-6-9-11-12

campillo had a strong tenth but came out in the 11th and 12th and got outworked...he lost the fight on the last two rounds.

How could you give him round 9 and 10? Especially round 9 which was the best round for Campillo, he was absolutely dominant in that round!

[calamaro]

Thatīs bull****, Cloud landed less than 10 punchs in the 11th and Campillo landed more than 20, how can u score the round to Cloud if even the refere stopped the fight to check Tavoris cut after a combination of Campillo. Bah!

[LEATHERF8CE]

I gave 1, 4, 6 and 12 to Cloud. So that's 114-112 Campillo. That's about as far as you can go with Cloud, those 4 rounds. I have to admit though, watching the actual fight after reading the RBR discussions from my phone and seeing Cloud get bashed for his performance and compared to Calzaghe-Lacy, I thought it was really bad. I panicked in the fight after Cloud had won that 10-7 round, 4th round, and 6th round(on my scorecard) I'm like, hold on a second, this fight is gonna be closer than I thought, this ain't no Calzaghe-Lacy. In the late rounds there might have been 2 close rounds that could have been given to Cloud, but I only gave him one. The fact is, it was a great fight that was tarnished by that 116-110 scorecard.

If the judges really wanted to push it, they could have made it a draw. But they went overboard by giving the fight to Cloud.

Ya, there were quite of bit of posters that were comparing this fight to Calzaghe - Lacy fight ..it was no doubt closer than what everybody made it to be....