Who has a better resume Andre Berto or Lucian Bute?

[$tate of Mind]

Berto notables:

Collazo

Quintana

Urango

Zavec

Bute notables:

Bika

Johnson

Andrade

Miranda

[Cardinal Buck]

Berto, but Bute has been more impressive against his opponents.

[-Kev-]

Both guys need to step it up=I know it's Berto but I don't wanna pick him.

You just put a scapegoat for Berto haters to not pick Berto

That's why polls should just be straight up, yes or no polls. Not yes, no, and cookies. Idiots will pick cookies.

[SCtrojansbaby]

Is this a serious question? Glen Johnson is 10x better than anybody Berto has beaten

[4Corners]

Berto, but his isn't all that great either. Bute's best win is still a way past it Johnson. Berto, if he loses to Ortiz again, I don't see him every coming back to be anything of a serious contender at Welterweight. Bute will beat Froch, if they fight, but no way he beats Andre.

[$tate of Mind]

Is this a serious question? Glen Johnson is 10x better than anybody Berto has beaten

With all due respect to GJ, he was like 1,000 years old when Bute beat him. He was WAY past his prime.

[$tate of Mind]

Both guys are lacking a marquee win.

[915angel]

should be ANDRE ward! not berto

[$tate of Mind]

should be ANDRE ward! not berto

Ward's resume smashes Bute's, it's no contest. Berto's and Bute's resumes are more comparable.

[-Kev-]

Is this a serious question? Glen Johnson is 10x better than anybody Berto has beaten

This is your logic right here...


Hopkins>Any one on Floyd's resume.

Calzaghe has a win over Hopkins.

Calzaghe's resume>Mayweather's resume.

See how ****** it is?

One really good win doesn't mean>a whole resume.