prime iceman scully vs prime butterbean who wins it? 5 rounder

[dino]

i say iceman scully outboxes butterbean for 2-3 rounds..then butterbean catches him with a haymacker...ko 4 butterbean

[THE REAL NINJA]

don't know i never got to see scully fight ...

[joeboxer]

There was a "prime" Butterbean?

[Easy-E]

i say iceman scully outboxes butterbean for 2-3 rounds..then butterbean catches him with a haymacker...ko 4 butterbean

ice was a cruiser, and was never knocked down in a fight
scully dominates this wanna be anyways

[TheBlackWallStreet]

Tough one. If the ICEMAN can stay away from the bombs butterbean throws then a easy win for him. But if BB can catch him with one of those shots it might be lights out ICEMAN.

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

Butterbean way too slow and inexperienced (forget the 60 fights at 4 rounds with lower teir opposition. I couldnt KO him and wouldnt even try... but he wouldn't hit me either. It's an insult to even have this brought up

[TuPrincipe]

I remember seeing an article on how Butterbean thought he could beat the Tysons, Evanders, and Lewis' of the world.

[Eric Persson]

Butterbean way too slow and inexperienced (forget the 60 fights at 4 rounds with lower teir opposition. I couldnt KO him and wouldnt even try... but he wouldn't hit me either. It's an insult to even have this brought up

Of all the matches involving you they could have discussed, Butterbean is what is brought to the table. That's a slap in the face if I ever saw one, haha.

[jack_the_rippuh]

Butterbean way too slow and inexperienced (forget the 60 fights at 4 rounds with lower teir opposition. I couldnt KO him and wouldnt even try... but he wouldn't hit me either. It's an insult to even have this brought up

Straight from The Iceman's fingers.

[Rockin']

I remember watching Scully box on ESPN. He was a good fighter.

Butterbean would pose no threat to Scully what so ever. They list Butterbean as being 5'11-1/2", thats a bunch of ****. I fought on a card with the guy and he was shorter than I was. I stood about 5'9-1/2" and his little bald head came up to my nose about.

The height descrepancy aside, Butterbean can not fight. John Scully can. The difference in weight would be no factor when Butterbean is forced to face Scullys skill. Its a mismatch. John would have made him look like the amatuer that he is.

Bill Miller remembers when John was down at Galaxy working with James in preperation for James' bout with Prince Charles Williams. "John Scully could fight, hes a good fighter..." When asked how Scully would fair against Butterbean, Bill shook his head almost in disgust, "John would punch him full of holes"!


Rockin'