how many prime hall of famers did Mayweather beat

[Luilun]

curious.....

How many were in their Prime ? Mosley and Delahoya way past prime the other Marquez was 2 weight classes below him.

[Rip Chudd]

He beat Berto....

who was an undefeated future HOF himself


that alone promotes Ortiz to the status of First ballot HOF

no doubt

LOL, always good for a laugh Maniac.

[no_frame]

zab is a hof?

he had that talent but he never seems to pull thru when it mattered

[Daniel Alpha]

Juan Manuel Marquez
Arturo Gatti
victor Ortiz
Shane Mosley
Zab Judah
Carlos Baldomir



all prime HOF's in my book

LOL... well, at least maniac said in his book.

[daggum]

phillip ndou 31-1 with 30 knockouts. don't bother looking at his boxrec it's filled with great fighters.

[Rip Chudd]

phillip ndou 31-1 with 30 knockouts. don't bother looking at his boxrec it's filled with great fighters.

The real question is: How many prime HOF fighters did Calzaghe beat? I counted 46

[daggum]

The real question is: How many prime HOF fighters did Calzaghe beat? I counted 46

if you count fantasy wins(who doesn't) he has beaten thousands of all time greats.

[EMACULATE]

Okay let just get this straight Shane wasnt prime and you can add the following as guys he beat in his prime that will go to the Hall of Fame. Some may not be in the hall of fame but prime is definitely no question.
Hernandez
Manfreddy
Corrales
Delahoya-past prime
Hatton
Argustus
Corley- Questionable but a gatekeeper for the 140 division
Judah- great talent but no heart or will to perform at the elete level
Castillo
N-DOU-FLOYD DESTROYED THIS POWER PUNCHER
Mosley- Not prime but was avoided by roach and PAC.
Ortiz- Not prime but young and strong
Baldomir- good win but easy work for floyd

[lfc19titles]

0

Oscar was no way in his prime, coming off a huge layoff, lost his speed and ability to sustain a top 12 round performance

Mosley was nearly 40 for christ sake and was coming off a near 2 year lay off

marquez was a lightweight

judah was coming off a loss, he was exposed already

corrales is the only one maybe

[Tamis!]

IMO, Chico and Castillo are the only prime (future) HOF'ers Floyd beat.

And sad to say, they're not even first balloters.