Your Top 5 Fighters in every Division!!

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Easy-E
    Gotta want it
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jul 2005
    • 22686
    • 865
    • 1,739
    • 32,777

    #11
    Originally posted by JUYJUY
    Why is that?
    audley "the unproven" harrison is your number three heavyweight
    haye has 14 wins and one loss and is your top cruiser??
    you have johnson and adamek above the undisputed champ tarver
    you have joe, kessler and froch above lacy at super middle, even though none of them have dominated good fighters like lacy has
    im ok with joe, bc hes a champ, but kess;er and froch above lacy is a joke
    winky is first in two different divisions, choose one
    how is floyd the third light welter?
    andddd i dont really feel like doing this anymore

    Comment

    • JUYJUY
      NSB P4P #1
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Apr 2005
      • 4292
      • 195
      • 10
      • 11,189

      #12
      Originally posted by PBF34
      audley "the unproven" harrison is your number three heavyweight
      haye has 14 wins and one loss and is your top cruiser??
      you have johnson and adamek above the undisputed champ tarver
      you have joe, kessler and froch above lacy at super middle, even though none of them have dominated good fighters like lacy has
      im ok with joe, bc hes a champ, but kess;er and froch above lacy is a joke
      winky is first in two different divisions, choose one
      how is floyd the third light welter?
      andddd i dont really feel like doing this anymore
      I'm basing it on ability dude, and based on ability Audley Harrison ranks highly in an awful HW division.

      Johnson battered Jones Jr in a one-sided beatdown far more emphatically than Tarver did (when you take away one punch), and Johnson beat Tarver (and Tarver won't fight him again because he knows Johnson had an off-night last time), and Johnson clearly beat Woods twice. And I don't even rate Johnson!

      Calzaghe, Froch and Kessler are more talented than Lacy in my opinion, and would all beat Lacy at their best.

      Winky would beat Taylor and Hopkins in my opinion.

      Mayweather has just one title win at 140 (against a washed-up Gatti), Tszyu dominated the division for 10 years.
      Last edited by JUYJUY; 11-12-2005, 10:17 PM.

      Comment

      • Easy-E
        Gotta want it
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Jul 2005
        • 22686
        • 865
        • 1,739
        • 32,777

        #13
        Originally posted by JUYJUY
        I'm basing it on ability dude, and based on ability Audley Harrison ranks highly in an awful HW division.

        Johnson destroyed Jones Jr far more emphatically than Tarver (when you take away one punch), and Johnson beat Tarver (and Tarver won't fight him again because he knows Johnson had an off-night last time), and Johnson clearly beat Woods twice. And I don't even rate Johnson!

        Calzaghe, Froch and Kessler are more talented than Lacy in my opinion, and would all beat Lacy at their best.

        Winky would beat Taylor and Hopkins in my opinion.

        Mayweather has just one title win at 140 (against a washed-up Gatti), Tszyu dominated the division for 10 years.
        you dont think floyd is more talented than hatton and zoo?

        notice how you based some of your list on ability, and the other part of your list on accomplishments
        your biased

        Comment

        • JUYJUY
          NSB P4P #1
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Apr 2005
          • 4292
          • 195
          • 10
          • 11,189

          #14
          Originally posted by PBF34
          you dont think floyd is more talented than hatton and zoo?

          notice how you based some of your list on ability, and the other part of your list on accomplishments
          your biased
          If Mayweather fought Tsyzu instead of Hatton fighting Tszyu, I know I'd of put all my money on Tszyu.

          Comment

          • Easy-E
            Gotta want it
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Jul 2005
            • 22686
            • 865
            • 1,739
            • 32,777

            #15
            Originally posted by JUYJUY
            If Mayweather fought Tsyzu instead of Hatton fighting Tszyu, I know I'd of put all my money on Tszyu.
            .....floyd is one of the most talented boxers ever, but enough about that, what about rating two people above the undisputed champ?

            Comment

            • Tha Greatest
              boxingscene legend
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Jul 2004
              • 15748
              • 616
              • 963
              • 24,468

              #16
              Originally posted by PBF34
              you dont think floyd is more talented than hatton and zoo?

              notice how you based some of your list on ability, and the other part of your list on accomplishments
              your biased
              ooo shytttt! BRUTAL :PWNAGE!

              Comment

              • No-mas-tias
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Oct 2005
                • 1914
                • 73
                • 2
                • 18,042

                #17
                Wow, I knew Cotto had some haters in here but to rank Freitas, Gatti and Harris above him?

                Comment

                • JUYJUY
                  NSB P4P #1
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Apr 2005
                  • 4292
                  • 195
                  • 10
                  • 11,189

                  #18
                  Originally posted by cotto#1p4p
                  Wow, I knew Cotto had some haters in here but to rank Freitas, Gatti and Harris above him?
                  I forgot about Cotto! Just edited him in, sorry

                  Comment

                  • unity768
                    Contender
                    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                    • May 2005
                    • 172
                    • 9
                    • 0
                    • 6,441

                    #19
                    Heavyweight
                    1. Lamon Brewster
                    2. Chris Byrd
                    3. James Toney
                    4. Wladamir Klitschko
                    5. Hasim Rahman
                    Crusierweight
                    1. Jean-Marc Mormeck
                    2. Guillermo Jones
                    3. O'Neil Bell
                    4. Dale Brown
                    5. Steve Cunningham
                    Light-Heavyweight
                    1. Antonio Tarver
                    2. Glen Johnson
                    3. Clinton Woods
                    4. Fabrice Tiozzo
                    5. Julio Gonzalez
                    Super Middleweight
                    1. Joe Calzaghe
                    2. Jeff Lacy
                    3. Mikkel Kessler
                    4. Markus Beyer
                    5. Danny Green
                    Middleweight
                    1. Jermain Taylor
                    2. Bernard Hopkins
                    3. Ronald Wright
                    4. Felix Sturm
                    5. Arthur Abraham
                    Junior Middleweight
                    1. Roman Karmazin
                    2. Daniel Santos
                    3. Kassim Ouma
                    4. Ricardo Mayorga
                    5. Fernando Vargas
                    Welterweight
                    1. Zab Judah
                    2. Antonio Margarito
                    3. Cory Spinks
                    4. Shane Mosley
                    5. Sharmba Mitchell
                    Junior Welterweight
                    1. Ricky Hatton
                    2. Floyd Mayweather
                    3. Kostya Tszyu
                    4. Miguel Cotto
                    5. Junior Witter
                    Lightweight
                    1. Jose Luis Castillo
                    2. Diego Corrales
                    3. Acelino Freitas
                    4. Juan Diaz
                    5. Zahir Raheem
                    Super Featherweight
                    1. Marco Antonio Barrera
                    2. Manny Pacquiao
                    3. Erik Morales
                    4. Jorge Barrios
                    5. Carlos Hernandez

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP