How good of a judge is Harold Lederman?

[noekin3]

awful judge.......sometimes im literary thinking "how in the hell he gave the round to x fighter"..........

[MJ223]

I think he gets caught up n the hype sometimes.... I like his daughter better

[Punker]

Lederman is a joke. A paid judge looking to score fights in HBO's best interest.

[Hitman18]

Absolutely ridiculous. Hes terrible. One fighter could dominate the other, and he gives it to the dominated fighter, maybe because they are the HBO fighter or the champ or just someone he personally prefers, but sometimes I am just shocked at his scoring.

[Furn]

It depends if he is scoring the fight for fighter I want to win.

But seriously isn't his job to give us an indication of what the real judges would have it. So in that sense he does ok as he is usually pretty close, sometimes

[jtcs1981]

Last couple of years, awful. You cant tell, that Max and Larry dont approve his scorecards lately. At the beginning they kept quite, but recently, specially Max, they argue his scores and his reasoning. Sometimes I think he is not even watching and he is waiting for Jim to say: He might stole the round in that last couple of seconds with that combination. His daughter is pretty good. But him, is time to retire.