Comments Thread For: “Fighting Words” – A Rivalry Without a Resolution

[Forza]

Trilogy over, JMM won 2 out of 3 fights

JMM is the superior fighter in every aspect

[indystress]

Trilogy over, JMM won 2 out of 3 fights

JMM is the superior fighter in every aspect

actually my friend, without the scoring error in the first fight, pac is 3-0 vs marquez.
funny how marquez fans believe marquez won 2 out of 3, even as far as all three.
but the majority of the best judges in boxing who scored the three fights saw different.
i myself had the first two fights 115-113, the third fight i had pac winning 116-112, and thats being generous being that pac outlanded total punches 9 rounds to 1 with two even rounds...and pac outlanded power punches 8 rounds to 4....as well as outlanded total punches by about 40 punches...not only did pac outlanded and threw more punches, pac was the aggressor all nite...MARQUEZ SUPERIOR? in the first two fights, if maquez didnt fumble the ball, he couldve won...in the last fight, if marquez tried to score instead of playing "prevent defense", then maybe he couldve won. but no rip offs here...pac won clear

[Forza]

actually my friend, without the scoring error in the first fight, pac is 3-0 vs marquez.
funny how marquez fans believe marquez won 2 out of 3, even as far as all three.
but the majority of the best judges in boxing who scored the three fights saw different.
i myself had the first two fights 115-113, the third fight i had pac winning 116-112, and thats being generous being that pac outlanded total punches 9 rounds to 1 with two even rounds...and pac outlanded power punches 8 rounds to 4....as well as outlanded total punches by about 40 punches...not only did pac outlanded and threw more punches, pac was the aggressor all nite...MARQUEZ SUPERIOR? in the first two fights, if maquez didnt fumble the ball, he couldve won...in the last fight, if marquez tried to score instead of playing "prevent defense", then maybe he couldve won. but no rip offs here...pac won clear

All the boxers agree marquez beat the **** out of pac. Deal with it

[Lope Sarreal]

pride

Thank God , He answered Manny's prayer. Nobody got hurt, except the Mexican Pride. Adios amigos.

[Best in Boxing]

So, Marquez is to Pacquiao what Jose Louis Castillo is to Floyd Jr.?

Nice try but, floyd won first fight closely and DOMINATED the rematch. wasn't even a question after that one.... whereas pac-jmm .....

[Lope Sarreal]

marcoviniciobarrios
hasta el dia de ayer many se merecia todo el respeto de los mexicanos, sibien el no tubo la culpa de la decicion unanime de los tres jueces, si la tiene en fingir que el es ganador cuando sabe perfectamente que no fue asi, como puede aspirar a gobernar un pais como filipinas cuando hemos visto q ni el mismo es honesto? sin duda se a ganado el desprecio de los mexicanos que tanro lo respetabamos por su ejemplar acctuacion dentro y fuera del ring. mal por ti many soy mexicano y te admiraba y respetaba hasta el dia de ayer. no vales la pena ni como boxeador ni persona, no estas a la altura de MARQUEZ, $@%! YOU PHILIPINOless

11 Hours Ago

[Lope Sarreal]

until the day yesterday Manya deserved all the respect of the Mexicans, sibi tube not to blame for the unanimous decicion of the three judges, if you have to pretend that he is a winner if you know perfectly well that it was not so, how can aspire to govern a country like the Philippines as we have seen neither the same q is honest? no doubt to win the scorn of the Mexican tanren acctuacion respected for his exemplary inside and outside the ring. Many bad for you I'm Mexican and I admired and respected until the day yesterday. not worth no person or as a boxer, you're not up to MARQUEZ, $ @%! You PHILIPINOless

[hillbilly]

Nice try but, floyd won first fight closely and DOMINATED the rematch. wasn't even a question after that one.... whereas pac-jmm .....

Mayweather lost the first fight with Castillo in my opinion. But it was a tough fight to judge. Educated observers split about 50/50 on it (press row, Lederman, etc.). So, it is hard to definitively say "floyd won first fight." And, he didn't "dominate" the rematch. He won it, but very few people objected to the 115-113 scorecards.

The difference between the fights--Marquez is a first ballot Hall of Famer. Castillo will never get near the HOF. So Mayweather went life or death with a very good, but certainly not great fighter, whereas Pacquiao did so with a Hall of Famer. There is big difference there in perception.

[hillbilly]

All the boxers agree marquez beat the **** out of pac. Deal with it

"All the boxers agree"--that is a ****** statement that is just wrong. I know plenty of professional boxers that think the exact opposite. That the fights are as controversial as they have been is the best evidence that neither fighter "beat the ****" out of the other in any match.

[delpilar]

Would this fight turn Floyd into a pitbull from a duck?