prime for prime.. could manny of beat shane at 135

[boxingking500]

just trying to find out the general consensus on this

could pacman beat shane at 135 prime vs. prime

[Mr Randy Watson]

no way in hell... shane was a beast at lw

[Rassclot]

Pac sparks him.


Is Shane greater than Morales. JMM and Barrera?

[Und1sputed619]

Shane was on PED's @ the time an so is Manny. I can't pick either one.

[bojangles1987]

Could he have? Not only could he, he would. Go look at who Mosley fought at lightweight. Yes he was a physical specimen, but people go ridiculously overboard about Mosley at lightweight.

Mosley's a brawler. No one between 122-140 other than a VERY select few is winning a firefight against Manny Pacquiao.

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

Sounds like a fantasy fight...therefore, Pac gets ****d by Shane.

[Bombs]

Of course he would. Manny would have annihilated a younger Mosley due to the fact that a younger roided up Mosley was more willing to exchange and open up.

[sunny31]

Hard to say...you are talking about one of the better lightweights of all time against one of the best of all time period I think manny is the better all round fighter, a much more rounded fighter but I don't see him avoiding prime shanes speed and power, I don't think PAC could take that type of punching power, so I go with Shane by ko/tko

[Barry Halls]

Hard to say...you are talking about one of the better lightweights of all time against one of the best of all time period I think manny is the better all round fighter, a much more rounded fighter but I don't see him avoiding prime shanes speed and power, I don't think PAC could take that type of punching power, so I go with Shane by ko/tko

could you define "one of the better"?

[ИATAS]

Pacquiao's record in fantasy fights is 1-143, so obviously he would lose. He's a terrible fantasy fighter