Rank these fighters based on ability 1-5 Floyd, Ward, Donaire, Pacquiao, Martinez

[UglyPug]

Scoring Criteria (in relation to weight/size) on scale of 1-10
Offense: (1) Speed, (2) Power, (3) Footwork (mobility and foot speed), (4) Jab, (5) Straight, (6) Hooks, (7) Uppercuts, (8) Combinations
Defense: (9) Blocking, (10) Head and Upperbody Movement
Intangibles: (11) Heart, (12) Chin, (13) Ring IQ ("read and react"), (14) Stamina

Donaire: (1) 10, (2) 10, (3) 9, (4) 6, (5) 8, (6) 9, (7) 6, (8) 8, (9) 6, (10) 7, (11) 7*, (12) 7*, (13) 8, (14) 7* TOTAL:108

Mayweather: (1) 10, (2) 6, (3) 7, (4) 8, (5) 10, (6) 10, (7) 8, (8) 8, (9) 9, (10) 10, (11) 7*, (12) 8, (13) 10, (14) 9 TOTAL: 120

Pacquiao: (1) 10, (2) 10, (3) 9, (4) 6, (5) 10, (6) 10, (7) 7, (8) 10, (9) 6, (10) 5, (11) 10, (12) 9, (13) 6, (14) 10 TOTAL: 118

Ward: (1) 8, (2) 5, (3) 8, (4) 8, (5) 8, (6) 8, (7) 7, (8) 8, (9) 8, (10) 7, (11) 7*, (12) 7*, (13) 8, (14) 8 TOTAL: 105

Martinez: (1) 9, (2) 8, (3) 10, (4) 8, (5) 10, (6) 7, (7) 6, (8) 7, (9) 4, (10) 8, (11) 10, (12) 8, (13) 8, (14) 7 TOTAL: 110

* - denotes lack of data - we simply have not seen that aspect of their game come into play.

PLEASE ask me if you have any questions about how/why I scored a fighter's ability. I tried to take into account opponents they have fought, and other more subjective aspects of the game when scoring. Of course you are going to disagree with me - so let me know, and we'll figure it out!

[UglyPug]

BUMP-age! come on colleagues! i put so much time and thought into this! FEEDBACK!

[Kagami Taiga]

Scoring Criteria (in relation to weight/size) on scale of 1-10
Offense: (1) Speed, (2) Power, (3) Footwork (mobility and foot speed), (4) Jab, (5) Straight, (6) Hooks, (7) Uppercuts, (8) Combinations
Defense: (9) Blocking, (10) Head and Upperbody Movement
Intangibles: (11) Heart, (12) Chin, (13) Ring IQ ("read and react"), (14) Stamina

Donaire: (1) 10, (2) 10, (3) 9, (4) 6, (5) 8, (6) 9, (7) 6, (8) 8, (9) 6, (10) 7, (11) 7*, (12) 7*, (13) 8, (14) 7* TOTAL:108

Mayweather: (1) 10, (2) 6, (3) 7, (4) 8, (5) 10, (6) 10, (7) 8, (8) 8, (9) 9, (10) 10, (11) 7*, (12) 8, (13) 10, (14) 9 TOTAL: 120

Pacquiao: (1) 10, (2) 10, (3) 9, (4) 6, (5) 10, (6) 10, (7) 7, (8) 10, (9) 6, (10) 5, (11) 10, (12) 9, (13) 6, (14) 10 TOTAL: 118

Ward: (1) 8, (2) 5, (3) 8, (4) 8, (5) 8, (6) 8, (7) 7, (8) 8, (9) 8, (10) 7, (11) 7*, (12) 7*, (13) 8, (14) 8 TOTAL: 105

Martinez: (1) 9, (2) 8, (3) 10, (4) 8, (5) 10, (6) 7, (7) 6, (8) 7, (9) 4, (10) 8, (11) 10, (12) 8, (13) 8, (14) 7 TOTAL: 110

* - denotes lack of data - we simply have not seen that aspect of their game come into play.

PLEASE ask me if you have any questions about how/why I scored a fighter's ability. I tried to take into account opponents they have fought, and other more subjective aspects of the game when scoring. Of course you are going to disagree with me - so let me know, and we'll figure it out!

this is pretty good actually, i might disagree on a few minor points but pretty good nonetheless.

[PEANUT BOSS]

nice mayweather gets caught with atleast 3 good lefts from ortiz

1. Floyd
2. Martinez
3.Ward
4.Donaire
5.Pacquiao

assuming you mean skills by ability and tbh Manny is not really that skilled he has other gifts like unbelievable conditioning and great chin

[Carpe Diem]

1. Floyd Mayweather(Most complete all-around Boxer)
2. Nonito Donaire( One of the most complete Boxers in Boxing)
3. Andre Ward(One of the most versatile Boxers in Boxing)
4. Manny Pacquiao(One of the toughest, and most athletic Boxers in Boxing)
5. Sergio Martinez

[tangalog2200]

nice mayweather gets caught with atleast 3 good lefts from ortiz

well manny won't get to be the p4p king, fotd and so many times foty and 8 weight division champ for nothing...

so he's top honcho now...

donaire
floyd
martinez
ward

[Pullcounter]

These are my rankings: 1. Floyd Mayweather (easily the best fighter in the world) 2. Sergio Martinez (he just continues to get better and better) 3. Nonito Donaire (great skills and talent, I wish
he fought more) 4. Manny Pacquiao (as great as he is he's very over rated imo, his recent fights have been a joke) 5. Andre Ward (has the best pure boxing skills on this list outside of Floyd and Nonito) If B-Hop beats Dawson I would put him at # 2 but he is past his prime. What are your rankings.

based on ability or athleticism

1. Pacquaio: too much speed, too much power and carries it up in weight, also southpaw. has a good chin. almost the complete package athletically.

2. Nonito: speed and power, dunno if it will carry up in weight, a lot of potential, but that's what it really is at this point, potential.

3. Wifebeater: speed and reflexes. below average chin and average power.

4. Martinez: good speed, good power, but in the past has taken rounds off, possibly a problem with this conditioning, but always has a second win.

5. Ward: good speed, average power... not that great and doesn't really belong on this list

based on traditional boxing skills only

1. wifebeater
2. nonito
3. pacquiao
4. martinez
5. ward

[minasyan]

manny pacquiao
floyd mayweather
sergio martinez
nonito donaire
andre ward

[Johnwoo8686]

Scoring Criteria (in relation to weight/size) on scale of 1-10
Offense: (1) Speed, (2) Power, (3) Footwork (mobility and foot speed), (4) Jab, (5) Straight, (6) Hooks, (7) Uppercuts, (8) Combinations
Defense: (9) Blocking, (10) Head and Upperbody Movement
Intangibles: (11) Heart, (12) Chin, (13) Ring IQ ("read and react"), (14) Stamina

Donaire: (1) 10, (2) 10, (3) 9, (4) 6, (5) 8, (6) 9, (7) 6, (8) 8, (9) 6, (10) 7, (11) 7*, (12) 7*, (13) 8, (14) 7* TOTAL:108

Mayweather: (1) 10, (2) 6, (3) 7, (4) 8, (5) 10, (6) 10, (7) 8, (8) 8, (9) 9, (10) 10, (11) 7*, (12) 8, (13) 10, (14) 9 TOTAL: 120

Pacquiao: (1) 10, (2) 10, (3) 9, (4) 6, (5) 10, (6) 10, (7) 7, (8) 10, (9) 6, (10) 5, (11) 10, (12) 9, (13) 6, (14) 10 TOTAL: 118

Ward: (1) 8, (2) 5, (3) 8, (4) 8, (5) 8, (6) 8, (7) 7, (8) 8, (9) 8, (10) 7, (11) 7*, (12) 7*, (13) 8, (14) 8 TOTAL: 105

Martinez: (1) 9, (2) 8, (3) 10, (4) 8, (5) 10, (6) 7, (7) 6, (8) 7, (9) 4, (10) 8, (11) 10, (12) 8, (13) 8, (14) 7 TOTAL: 110

* - denotes lack of data - we simply have not seen that aspect of their game come into play.

PLEASE ask me if you have any questions about how/why I scored a fighter's ability. I tried to take into account opponents they have fought, and other more subjective aspects of the game when scoring. Of course you are going to disagree with me - so let me know, and we'll figure it out!

Judging from your previous post I would think you'd have Pacquiao rated above Mayweather, instead you have Mayweather above Pac. Strange

But my list goes
Pacquiao
Mayweather
Donaire
Martinez
Ward

[RubenSonny]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Nonito Donaire
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Andre Ward
5. Sergio Martinez

This is what I would put down, I feel a bit uneasy rating Donaire above Pac though.