Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Third Time May Be Charm For Prime Castillo

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Third Time May Be Charm For Prime Castillo

    Floyd Mayweather’s 6 round destruction of Arturo Gatti Jr this past June confirmed the near universal sentiment that the unbeaten 28 year old “Pretty Boy” is without peer in his weight classes and has achieved a level of pure domination equaled by few champions in ring history.

    In terms of ring generalship, speed of hand, punching accuracy and conditioning, Mayweather rivals the Sugar Ray Leonard of 1978 and the “Mantequilla Napoles” of the late 1960’s and early 1970’s. Whether he can occupy their stature once his career is over is an issue strongly in doubt.

    Mayweather is in a situation that has precedent. A decade ago Roy Jones Jr. was beginning his decade of domination in both the middleweight and light heavyweight class. Roy, like Floyd, was a study in brilliance and ring supremacy. Yet he never met a foeman truly worthy of his steel, one who dug deep into his heart and forced him to the precipice of defeat. You could point to the emergence of Antonio Tarver who defrocked Jones with a brutal two round knockout last May and registered a lopsided points verdict in their return earlier this month. [details]

  • #2
    I think that Castillo won the first fight. And i agree that Mayweather is a very talented fighter. But talented fighters have to fight great opponents to be considered great.
    Will a third fight with Castillo do it? maybe. But as of right now i think that Mayweather is overrated. He destroyed Gatti, big deal. Since when is Gatti considered a great boxer. Gatti is a brawler with a great heart. What about Bruselles? Well...what about Bruselles?
    And now the great mayweather fights Mitchell. Is this because he has had too many diffficult fights and needs an easy one? ... Please.
    I hopes Mitchell gives him hell.

    Comment


    • #3
      Mayweather does seem to take fights at well-timed moments and then capitalise greatly on its victory. But he is a fighter who i do not think can be matched in the speed, power and accuracy department. He's already beaten Castillo twice. he doesn't need to fight him again. I think a fight with Ricky Hatton or Winky Wright will surely place him among the greats if he wins.

      Comment


      • #4
        What the article says is true, but I think Hatton is a better test. Castillo is better now, but here you have a natural Jr. Welterweight who does all that Castillo does, but faster, and, in my opinion, better.

        Comment


        • #5
          This article is short on common sense.

          It starts out good, comparing Mayweather and Leonard, but there's no sense in matching Duran's name with Castillo's current place in boxing.

          A third fight with Castillo cannot elevate Mayweather in any possible way, unless he went toe-to-toe and dispelled all myths about his ability to truly rumble. Even then, it's still Castillo in there with him, not a prime Duran, so Mayweather proving his toughness might increase his PPV attractiveness but would not suddenly elevate him to greatness. Simply put, it would be another win over a guy he's beaten and is expected to beat again.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Moon
            This article is short on common sense.

            It starts out good, comparing Mayweather and Leonard, but there's no sense in matching Duran's name with Castillo's current place in boxing.

            A third fight with Castillo cannot elevate Mayweather in any possible way, unless he went toe-to-toe and dispelled all myths about his ability to truly rumble. Even then, it's still Castillo in there with him, not a prime Duran, so Mayweather proving his toughness might increase his PPV attractiveness but would not suddenly elevate him to greatness. Simply put, it would be another win over a guy he's beaten and is expected to beat again.
            You tell 'em how it is homeboy. I'd much rather see Mayweather against Hatton and a 34yr. old DLH, but to reiterate what you just said... For these other fights to happen he'll need a guy who is hot right now and that's Castillo

            Comment

            Working...
            X
            TOP