Comments Thread For: Bracing For The Fall: BScene Pound For Pound Update

[BIGPOPPAPUMP]

The more things change…

…well, in the mythical pound-for-pound race, they haven’t changed much at all lately. Staggered schedules and the dog days of summer haven’t left much wiggle room. Wladimir Klitschko kept the Heavyweight crown in July, and thus kept his slot, while British sensation Amir Khan made a case that he might be ready for a place of his own. [Click Here To Read More]

[Medved]

Post Reserved for 50 page battle


This list is a .....

Bradley but no KHAN?

Floyd??? Wtf, he hasnt fought in 16 months.

Donaire at #2? lol!!!!!

Martinez #3? Too high

Wlad needs to be in top 5.

Could care less about Froch/Ward being up there until we get a winner, dont think Froch is that good.

Dont agree with this list AT ALL

[fitefanSHO]

A shame Ghost Guerrero was injured. I think he would have beaten Maidana in such a way that people would have begun to start considering him seriously for a place in the lower half of the P4P Top 10. He looked really good against Katsidis, and a breakout win against Maidana could have put him over.

[Larry the boss]

Manny has 4 lineal titles..floyd has 3 but has defended his lineal titles alot more

[Pullcounter]

Manny has 4 lineal titles..floyd has 3 but has defended his lineal titles alot more

wifebeater grew a vagina and went on vacation. he drops due to inactivity.

[Sugar Q]

Donaire is good but #2? Based on what? So he hasnt fought in a while but he's #2 but Floyd has never loss but it affects these BS ratings? The fact that he's fighting a young, hungry lion while Manny is fighting retreads means nothing? I dont blame Floyd for saying **** most boxing media cause they'll never be satisfied. The real Top 5 should be:

1) Mayweather (Top Dawg)
2) Martinez (challenged Pac but got a "Hell No")
3) The Klitchsko Bros. (gotta give it up)
4) Pacquiao (Take the test and fight the best until then)
5) Ward (if he beats Froch he moves up to #4, then Bute #2)

[BesWorldChamp]

Donaire is good but #2? Based on what? So he hasnt fought in a while but he's #2 but Floyd has never loss but it affects these BS ratings? The fact that he's fighting a young, hungry lion while Manny is fighting retreads means nothing? I dont blame Floyd for saying **** most boxing media cause they'll never be satisfied. The real Top 5 should be:

1) Mayweather (Top Dawg)
2) Martinez (challenged Pac but got a "Hell No")
3) The Klitchsko Bros. (gotta give it up)
4) Pacquiao (Take the test and fight the best until then)
5) Ward (if he beats Froch he moves up to #4, then Bute #2)

Didn't he challenge Floyd also? Why no mention of that?

[Froghead99]

Bull**** list.

Floyd? The guy who hasn't fought in a year and a half?

Bradley? The guy who has only fought once as a JWW since the end of 2009? Are you ***ing serious?

JMM, the guy who ducked Khan AND Guerrero? JMM is a cherry picks with the best of them.

This list is utter horse****.

[newcastleking]

as for floyd having 0 losses ive seen em lose at least 2 but funny judges robbed the other guys. perfect records mean nothing look at what happened to juanma lopez or david lemeaux. they got beaten by guys with many losses.

[ShoulderRoll]

Amir Khan has had a nice run through some very good 140 pounders in Maidana and Judah. He belongs on the list; I wouldn't kick off Bradley though because he is deserving as well.

So...I would drop Klitschko (who looked less than scintillating against a scared David Haye with a bad toe) and slide Khan in at #10.

Otherwise good list. I'm glad to see Carl Froch finally getting some credit for his murderer's row of opposition. Best resume in the sport bar none.