Should Boxing be banned?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • cobracore
    Contender
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Jun 2005
    • 251
    • 27
    • 1
    • 6,518

    #31
    Okay, to help you out.

    There are several key points to be made here.

    1.Boxing has a huge history. It is one of the earliest forms of competitive sport. Due to it's history, it shouldn't be banned.

    2.Every single fighter in the industry is willing to partake - it's a choice. Should F1 racing be banned because someone crashed and died? No, because they knew the risks, and knew the benefits (cash, enjoyment, etc.) It's a choice. It's not like their forced to fight.

    3.It is well known that boxing keeps kids off the streets. It provides a road to a better, healthier way of life. Like someone said previously already, a lot of these fighters would be drug dealing and popping clips if they weren't in the gym everyday, training.

    4.You could argue that because in boxing, the intention to hurt another human being is there, therefore it should be banned.

    To this, i answer - is the intention of a boxer who is in the ring really to hurt the other person? Well, i'm sure it is some of the time - but as a sport, the intentions are not to hurt - the intentions are to display fighting prowess. I demonstrate my skill in punching, counterpunching, footwork, by fighting another man. If someone pitched a ball in baseball, and the dude with the bat hits the ball and it flies into the face of a fielder and kills him, should baseball be banned? No, because it wasn't intentional - the idea was for the batter to hit the ball as far as possible, not to kill someone. It was an accident.

    Injuries in boxing are mostly accident - no accident as in it happened by chance, but accident because the intention is not to hurt, but to display skill, to land punches.

    5.If boxing is banned, do you honestly think it'll stop? Humans like watching people fight. Thats why we had the gladiators. Thats why we have boxing. Banning boxing will not end the sport - it will only put an end to the proper business side. Instead, we will have people fighting in cages, with no rules, no medical support at hand, no proper judges, no proper protection for fighters, no proper ********. Look at prohibition - they banned it, and it still happened (in fact, it could be argued that more alcohol was consumed). If boxing is banned, all you do is put it onto to the black market, and make everything worse for all involved. Leave boxing legalized, and it's 5000% safer than if you ban it.

    Comment

    • doorAY
      Amateur
      • Oct 2005
      • 11
      • 12
      • 5
      • 6,323

      #32
      thanks for the help cobracore

      Comment

      • Moon
        Born Again Pagan
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Mar 2004
        • 1504
        • 90
        • 97
        • 7,814

        #33
        Banned, no. Better regulated, yes.

        Comment

        • Chups
          Banned
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • May 2004
          • 18400
          • 1,835
          • 1,281
          • 52,879

          #34
          Fink all of you!

          Comment

          • tracylee
            B Scene's Julia Roberts
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Apr 2004
            • 8181
            • 588
            • 865
            • 16,433

            #35
            Originally posted by Floydmayweather
            Everyone should stop being little bitches. Its a fair question whether or we like or not, dont insult new members. Say your peace , but be a man.
            and I did just that.......I was very polite and manly in my reply

            Comment

            • Gattz187
              Contender
              Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
              • Nov 2004
              • 434
              • 29
              • 9
              • 6,755

              #36
              if they ban boxing then they should ban every contact sport. football boxing ufc rugby etc would be banned.so i say no

              Comment

              • EXIGE
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • May 2005
                • 10154
                • 404
                • 461
                • 19,071

                #37
                No it shouldnt be banned. Car Crashes probably exceed deaths in Boxing, and the economic benefits boxing has are massive. now thats in the most basic form! 2 advantages, with a comparison to one other activity.

                To the person who said better regulated. Karma for you.

                Comment

                • xzworks
                  Randy Suico Fan
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Sep 2005
                  • 1847
                  • 260
                  • 333
                  • 12,107

                  #38
                  Originally posted by jack_the_rippuh
                  On behalf of all the boxingscene users, I'd like to issue an apology.
                  I'm sorry, but lots of the users are going through some problems right now... we aren't normally like this. We'd like to welcome you to the site and we apologize for being trolls to you.

                  Welcome, doorAY!
                  damn..jack the rippuh for admin.!!!

                  Comment

                  • xzworks
                    Randy Suico Fan
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Sep 2005
                    • 1847
                    • 260
                    • 333
                    • 12,107

                    #39
                    Originally posted by cobracore
                    Okay, to help you out.

                    There are several key points to be made here.

                    1.Boxing has a huge history. It is one of the earliest forms of competitive sport. Due to it's history, it shouldn't be banned.

                    2.Every single fighter in the industry is willing to partake - it's a choice. Should F1 racing be banned because someone crashed and died? No, because they knew the risks, and knew the benefits (cash, enjoyment, etc.) It's a choice. It's not like their forced to fight.

                    3.It is well known that boxing keeps kids off the streets. It provides a road to a better, healthier way of life. Like someone said previously already, a lot of these fighters would be drug dealing and popping clips if they weren't in the gym everyday, training.

                    4.You could argue that because in boxing, the intention to hurt another human being is there, therefore it should be banned.

                    To this, i answer - is the intention of a boxer who is in the ring really to hurt the other person? Well, i'm sure it is some of the time - but as a sport, the intentions are not to hurt - the intentions are to display fighting prowess. I demonstrate my skill in punching, counterpunching, footwork, by fighting another man. If someone pitched a ball in baseball, and the dude with the bat hits the ball and it flies into the face of a fielder and kills him, should baseball be banned? No, because it wasn't intentional - the idea was for the batter to hit the ball as far as possible, not to kill someone. It was an accident.

                    Injuries in boxing are mostly accident - no accident as in it happened by chance, but accident because the intention is not to hurt, but to display skill, to land punches.

                    5.If boxing is banned, do you honestly think it'll stop? Humans like watching people fight. Thats why we had the gladiators. Thats why we have boxing. Banning boxing will not end the sport - it will only put an end to the proper business side. Instead, we will have people fighting in cages, with no rules, no medical support at hand, no proper judges, no proper protection for fighters, no proper ********. Look at prohibition - they banned it, and it still happened (in fact, it could be argued that more alcohol was consumed). If boxing is banned, all you do is put it onto to the black market, and make everything worse for all involved. Leave boxing legalized, and it's 5000% safer than if you ban it.
                    cobracore for mod!!!!! NOW!!!

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP