TOUGHER TEST FOR Mayweather: Hatton or Judah

[Bozo_no no]

You guys really havent seen Hatton fight. He is really quick, and he forces you to fight his fight. He's not an unskilled brawler like people are making him out to be, .

The point is, Mayweather would MAKE HIM LOOK like an unskilled brawler.

I hate it when people assert "You haven't seen Hatton fight".

Do you think he's been a secret?

His fights have been televised for YEARS.

[Martin (Top Knowledge)]

TOUGHER TEST FOR Mayweather: Hatton or Judah..

Hatton easy... IMO

King Kostya Tszyu vs Jab Judah - TKO 2nd round WIN!

King Kostya Tszyu vs Ricky Hatton - TKO 12th round LOSS!

[trinidadpr87]

Hatton easy... IMO

King Kostya Tszyu vs Jab Judah - TKO 2nd round WIN!

King Kostya Tszyu vs Ricky Hatton - TKO 12th round LOSS!

Styles make fights.

[trinidadpr87]

I would say Zab because he's a southpaw with very good hand speed.Corley got a lot of shots in against Floyd and i think Zab would do the same but even better.

[Bozo_no no]

Hatton easy... IMO

King Kostya Tszyu vs Jab Judah - TKO 2nd round WIN!

King Kostya Tszyu vs Ricky Hatton - TKO 12th round LOSS!

For a guy who asserts he's all about boxing knowledge in his user name, it's funny you'd be so quick to use the time old ignorant rule of compairing opposition and acting like that holds any relevence in an entirely different fight.

That's weak man.

Foreman KO Frazier 2, KO Norton 1

Foreman and Norton W decision Ali

Ali vs Foreman = ????

[Mike_R]

yeah i really don't see hatton being as big a problem as some would make him out to be for floyd. but on the flipside- i would rather see floyd fight hatton- because it would silence a lot of people one way or another. and also i want to see a superfight before one of them picks up an L some how/some way. i think zab could beat floyd- but i think hatton v. floyd would have me more excited.

wow, that doesn't even make sense to me.

[RAESAAD]

I think they could both cause him sizeable problems in totally different ways....hell if you could morph Hatton and Judah together they would be the perfect answer to Floyd....Judahs skillz and straight left with Hattons stamina and pressure.

[masterdirector]

By Top Knowledge, I think he's referring to those toys.



And Margarito isn't any better than Hatton. He's sloppy, Judah and Mayweather both would beat him. Margarito is more powerful, but that's all he has.

Hatton is fast, but not as fast as Mayweather. Come on now, Mayweather is clearly faster. Or maybe you haven't seen him fight.

[ShowStopper]

I would say Judah...But I am a fan and simply consider him a better fighter...

[druth]

Hatton easy... IMO

King Kostya Tszyu vs Jab Judah - TKO 2nd round WIN!

King Kostya Tszyu vs Ricky Hatton - TKO 12th round LOSS!

You can't compare that, Martin. We're talkinga about Tszyu fighting at his prime, which he is out of now.

Hatton's style presented problems for Tszyu. Tszyu is a more skilled fighter, he just ran into a style that doesn't match up well with his.


As far as Hatton and Judah vs. Mayweather, Hatton once again presents more of a problem. I don't care for his style or his tactics, however he matches up very well with Floyd. He can take a punch, give a punch and NEVER stops. He's not even close to being as skilled as Tszyu, Mayweather or Judah, but his style matches up well with them.

You guys are giving Judah too much credit. He's fast but not in the same class as Mayweather; not even close. The problem he presents is being a southpaw, however Floyd is too good and too smart to let that bother him or to counter it. IF they fight (and that's a big IF), I see counter left hooks over top of the right jab all night long. Floyd keeps his right too high for those straight rights to land with any frequency.