I know when Floyd retired Pacquiao took the pound for pound #1 spot but if Im not mistaken floyd neve beat the #1 pound for pound fighter to take the #1 spot either right? so these 2 fighters fighting each other is very important to boxing in my opinion
Has Mayweather or Pacquiao either beat the #1 pound for pound fighter
Collapse
-
-
It's very rare to have two high ranked p4p fighters fight each other, let alone two guys that can both be argued p4p #1. You don't see the generally considered p4p best fighter lose to someone who immediately takes his spot that often, at least not recently. -
How often are the top fighters p4p in the same division..thats why fmj vs manny is so special only happens a few times in a lifetime. You dont gain p4p crown by just beating the number one its tour collective wins and the manner in which yiu dominate everytime you fight.Comment
-
PBF beat Marquez and Mosley when the both were considered #3 in the p4p list. Impressive for his last two fights but like it was said before its not often the top 2 p4p guys are in the same division. And not ony current p4p but maybe alltime.Comment
-
Exactly. marquez was actually Number 2 or 1, arguable at the time PBF beat him.
The argument when PBF returned was that JMM was number 2, but should be number 1 because they felt as though JMM won the fights, thats why the fight was billed as 'Numero UNO ".
So depending on where you ranked PBF (1-3) at the time he returned, that would have been the P4P 1 and 2 fighting each other, or the P4P 2-3, or 1-3.
people tend to forget that because of how easily floyd won.Comment
-
^^^^^^^Exactly. marquez was actually Number 2 or 1, arguable at the time PBF beat him.
The argument when PBF returned was that JMM was number 2, but should be number 1 because they felt as though JMM won the fights, thats why the fight was billed as 'Numero UNO ".
So depending on where you ranked PBF (1-3) at the time he returned, that would have been the P4P 1 and 2 fighting each other, or the P4P 2-3, or 1-3.
people tend to forget that because of how easily floyd won.
They sure do.....Comment
Comment