Has Mayweather or Pacquiao either beat the #1 pound for pound fighter

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • optkliluzn
    Contender
    • Mar 2008
    • 339
    • 14
    • 0
    • 6,656

    #1

    Has Mayweather or Pacquiao either beat the #1 pound for pound fighter

    I know when Floyd retired Pacquiao took the pound for pound #1 spot but if Im not mistaken floyd neve beat the #1 pound for pound fighter to take the #1 spot either right? so these 2 fighters fighting each other is very important to boxing in my opinion
  • bojangles1987
    bo jungle
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jul 2009
    • 41118
    • 1,326
    • 357
    • 63,028

    #2
    It's very rare to have two high ranked p4p fighters fight each other, let alone two guys that can both be argued p4p #1. You don't see the generally considered p4p best fighter lose to someone who immediately takes his spot that often, at least not recently.

    Comment

    • sweetscience18
      Interim Champion
      Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
      • May 2010
      • 884
      • 28
      • 7
      • 6,981

      #3
      Originally posted by optkliluzn
      I know when Floyd retired Pacquiao took the pound for pound #1 spot but if Im not mistaken floyd neve beat the #1 pound for pound fighter to take the #1 spot either right? so these 2 fighters fighting each other is very important to boxing in my opinion
      How often are the top fighters p4p in the same division..thats why fmj vs manny is so special only happens a few times in a lifetime. You dont gain p4p crown by just beating the number one its tour collective wins and the manner in which yiu dominate everytime you fight.

      Comment

      • dabezt2
        Contender
        Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
        • Apr 2011
        • 103
        • 0
        • 0
        • 6,147

        #4
        PBF beat Marquez and Mosley when the both were considered #3 in the p4p list. Impressive for his last two fights but like it was said before its not often the top 2 p4p guys are in the same division. And not ony current p4p but maybe alltime.

        Comment

        • intoccabile
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Sep 2006
          • 3038
          • 110
          • 0
          • 10,249

          #5
          Originally posted by dabezt2
          PBF beat Marquez and Mosley when the both were considered #3 in the p4p list. Impressive for his last two fights but like it was said before its not often the top 2 p4p guys are in the same division. And not ony current p4p but maybe alltime.
          Exactly. marquez was actually Number 2 or 1, arguable at the time PBF beat him.

          The argument when PBF returned was that JMM was number 2, but should be number 1 because they felt as though JMM won the fights, thats why the fight was billed as 'Numero UNO ".

          So depending on where you ranked PBF (1-3) at the time he returned, that would have been the P4P 1 and 2 fighting each other, or the P4P 2-3, or 1-3.

          people tend to forget that because of how easily floyd won.

          Comment

          • QADASHBANYAH
            Banned
            • Mar 2010
            • 1075
            • 69
            • 73
            • 1,211

            #6
            Originally posted by intoccabile
            Exactly. marquez was actually Number 2 or 1, arguable at the time PBF beat him.

            The argument when PBF returned was that JMM was number 2, but should be number 1 because they felt as though JMM won the fights, thats why the fight was billed as 'Numero UNO ".

            So depending on where you ranked PBF (1-3) at the time he returned, that would have been the P4P 1 and 2 fighting each other, or the P4P 2-3, or 1-3.

            people tend to forget that because of how easily floyd won.
            ^^^^^^^

            They sure do.....

            Comment

            Working...
            TOP