Should Ortiz Massively KO May...he goes on p4p list...but where?

[Ringlife]

I would say number one no doubt.

[extracurRICular]

I would say number one no doubt.

that's a bit hard for me to justify......I wouldn't place him over Sergio or Pac at this point.....but I'd have him for sure at 4 or 3....some people say that's too high!!!

[HughJass]

7 or 8 no higher

[extracurRICular]

7 or 8 no higher

why not 5?? middle of the pack???

[HughJass]

the guy has not fought enough top ten p4p his only notable fights are maidana berto peterson

[RockyB]

I'd put him at 6-8 or somewhere around there

[Cash Cow]

All Jokes aside I would say him beating undefeated Berto & Undefeated Mayweather he would deserve to be #3 behind Sergio #2 & Manny #1.

[Cash Cow]

the guy has not fought enough top ten p4p his only notable fights are maidana berto peterson

Who has Nonito Donaire fought that is "top ten p4p"?

Who has Timothy Bradley fought that is "top ten p4p"?

Ortiz beating Mayweather & Berto who are both undefeated and knocking out Mayweather which is what the scenario presents is better than anything that any of these guys below have done recently...

Nonito Donaire
Juan Manuel Márquez
Wladimir Klitschko
Timothy Bradley
Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
Giovani Segura
Andre Ward
Bernard Hopkins

[Pugilistic™]

I'd put him at 6.

Floyd might not be on the p4p list now but he is still arguably the best fighter in the world. He would be if he wasn't so inactive.

[FistoftheDallasStar]

It would be similar to how Sergio Martinez rose in the P4P list after destroying Paul Williams. I say definite top 5 for sure.