Who's better: Haye or Byrd?

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Before Wlad Klitschko Fight:

Byrd: 32-1-0
Haye: 25-1-0

Each fighter's Resume with wins over notable opponents:

Byrd's:
Vitali Klitschko (please don't comment... it's a "W" on his record)
David Tua (only other losses to Lewis and Ibeabuchi)
Holyfield (40 yo)
McCline
Williamson


Haye's:
Jean Marc Mormeck
Maccarinelli
Barrett (38 yo)
Valuev (38 yo)
Ruiz (39yo)
Harrison (39 yo)

[Walt Liquor]

anyone else wanna see tua blow valuev up? like explode his giant head into the fans...

[sunny31]

Haye if you compare their performances against Wlad, he did better than Byrd. I also think that Haye faced the better version of Wlad. The argument for Byrd is that he accomplished more in the division. I think if Haye carried on fighting he would surpass Byrd, which wouldn't be difficult btw

[Luilun]

Flip a coin they're two black dud's

[!! Mr. Soprano]

anyone else wanna see tua blow valuev up? like explode his giant head into the fans...

Are you kidding me? Tua is 5'11...