"IF" it happened at 168, James Toney vs Bernard Hopkins

[SnoopySmurf]

Who would win? Both are skilled inside fighters, it'd be hard to score.

EDIT : BOTH fighters are at their peak fitness at this weight.

[Playground]

Hopkins has never fought at the weight

[Truth]

I would say Toney would win. Remember this fight was signed and sealed in the summer of '03, then it got called off because of $$$$.

[Truth]

But wasn't that fight going to be at 190 in '03

I think so, but not positive...good question.

[AintGottaClue]

at 168 a Draw at 160 i go hopkins by SD, anythign above i guess i gotta go with toney

[Zab Super Judah]

i dont know. They are both naturall counter punches so im not too sure on this one

[m00ks]

Toney's got more technical skils, better hand speed and just as crafty if not more.

[Floydmayweather]

I would have to say Toney.