5 or 7 Judges Per TitleFight

[The Dreamer]

We need to have 5 Judges that are NEUTRAL, not belonging to anyone. Take the top industry people and have them watch 2000 fights and let them mark each round. Select the 4 highest people who get it "right". and the 5th judge would be a "internet" judge where fans vote for each round as it happens. Make some system where the bottom peoples votes arent counted. ie: if theres a round and its a CLEAR round for Fighter A and 10k people voted for Fighter B then ban all those people from voting ever again.

We need new changes, a big commitee of people who actually know what they are doing. make strict testing by having them watch tons of fights and giving their score cards and take the best of the crop and make em judges and if they screw up 1 fight on purpose get rid of them.

But it will never happen, theres always going to be 90 year old white senile tards who have no idea what they are doing.

The bold part is a terrible idea. Fans should never have a say in an official match.

I've said it before. There should be an official scoring oversight committee where controversial fights could be petitioned to be re-scored.

But for that to happen boxing as a whole would have to become unified sport with one set of uniform rules and governing body and I don't see that happening.

[Frogs!]

i think medved's advocating for a "boxing idol".

[Medved]

The bold part is a terrible idea. Fans should never have a say in an official match.

I've said it before. There should be an official scoring oversight committee where controversial fights could be petitioned to be re-scored.

But for that to happen boxing as a whole would have to become unified sport with one set of uniform rules and governing body and I don't see that happening.

Thats why you make a filter, and have a computer system which ranks each internet judge, im sure out of the thousands of boxing fans theres the top 0.1% who judge each round perfectly, im saying give these guys 1 vote combined.

Something like this:

During the course of the year they sit and watch a stream or tv feed for any fight they want and at end of every round they give it a score. Have the company go back and eliminate all the close rounds that could go either way and put the correct answers into the computer, then filter the people to those who out of 5000 rounds answered each one correctly. Say you have 500 people in the world who are die hard boxing fans and have gotten every round correct during the course of a year, then you give these guys a vote total. So during the next event they will all vote. Make them not know each other and they will call the fight fairly along with the 4 live judges. They wont screw up this badly, Im willing to bet if you get the top 0.1% of the people who score all rounds correctly during the year that they will get the correct call 99.99% of the time. Its way better than the current system of senile tards.

Not saying all judges should be internet but 1 out of 5. Its not like Bubba Joe in a trailer park will have a say in who wins but the best of the best round scorers vote on a round. So if 450 out of 500 score round for Fighter A thats what shows up.

or another system: Do what I said above, create some sort of program where fans can score each round for fun as they see fit, after like 500 fights a commision looks at who's the best Judge and offer them a 6 month contract as a temp judge and see where it goes from there.

With all the horrible judging that goes on theres no other way to get fresh breath into the Judging industry, most of these judges are senile morons who cant judge a round to save their life.

[The Dreamer]

i think medved's advocating for a "boxing idol".

You'd have to watch the fight and tune in the next day for the results show.

[Frogs!]

You'd have to watch the fight and tune in the next day for the results show.

tbh, i like his idea.

it wouldn't hurt to have a jennifer lopez in between rds to tell us what she thinks about the fight.