Comments Thread For: Make Room For Super Middles: Pound for Pound Update

[D4thincarnation]

Really impressed by Boxingscene, p4p ranking, much better than the Ring or Boxrec. Don't agree with them 100% but the list is very similar to mine.

Who makes the list?

[David Struck]

Make Room For Super Middles: Pound for Pound Update

Ismayl Sillakh should be #1 - he's awesome, baby!!!

[Fetta]

Regardless of he doesnt fight or not the moment Money came back he should have been number 1, Nonito at number 2 cause of a fight in 2007 and a knockout this year (great knockout but come on number 5 at best on my list), Martinez (who also has a great knockout and has beaten all comers) the man that gets no respect and my number 2 P4P. I like the rest of list except Froch should be lower than Ward and i dont think head butt Bradley should be on this list. maybe one day but not today.

[UglyPug]

If there were an 11th slot, abner mares belongs there.

i dont think mayweather should be on the list at al because he's been inactive for over a year. but yeah, we all know that he really is number 2 right now. a victory over ortiz still isn't enough to put him at number 1, but it will solidify him at number 2 over donaire and martinez.

[Pullcounter]

i'm glad froch is on there and above ward. I can't put ward above froch because every fight was a hometown fight

[LeadUppercut]

At last, someone is finally recognising Carl Froch, not only as p4p top but as being rated higher than Ward – which indeed he should be.

About time.

Take a photo, because he aint gonna be there for long

[LeadUppercut]

floyd announcing that he's going to fight again, makes him number 4 p4p in the list? like, wtf??? Mr Rold what's up with that?

Common-sense ?

Oh sorry, a dirty word.

[LeadUppercut]

ismayl sillakh should be #1 - he's awesome, baby!!!

[SirTomJones]

Froch no.7 and about time!

Says a lot about the state of boxing right now haha.

[LeadUppercut]

If there were an 11th slot, abner mares belongs there.

i dont think mayweather should be on the list at al because he's been inactive for over a year. but yeah, we all know that he really is number 2 right now. a victory over ortiz still isn't enough to put him at number 1, but it will solidify him at number 2 over donaire and martinez.

Agreed, sucks that Martinez cant land a defining fight.

ANd mares will have a great body-of-work under his belt if he gets by Agbeko.

Where do you see Mares, Cliff? Would you have hiim in the top 15 ?