Who did better after their 2nd match-up: Marquez or Pacquiao

[JourneymanUK]

Regardless of your opinion regarding the outcome of their previous two meetings, who did better for their respective legacies, Juan Manuel or Manny?

Juan Manuel Marquez: 52-5-1

Michael Katsidis W TKO 9
Juan Diaz W UD
Floyd Mayweather Jr UD
Juan Diaz W TKO 9
Joel Casamayor W TKO 11

Total Fights after 2nd Match: 5 (Won 4 Lost 1)


Manny Pacquiao: : 53-3-2

Shane Mosley W UD
Antonio Margarito W UD
Joshua Clottey W UD
Miguel Cotto W TKO 11
Ricky Hatton W KO 2
Oscar dela Hoya W RTD 8
David Diaz TKO 9

Total Fights after 2nd Match: 7 (Won 7 Lost 0)

Poll included.

[Clyde Barrow]

Both won another lineal title and a couple paper belts. Both guys beat some decent fighters. No way should JMM's loss to PBF count against him. But Pac's win on Cotto beats any of JMM's wins, so Pac edges it.

[Jabroni]

Don't get me wrong, I like Floyd and I am a *****, but if Marquez destroys David Diaz in a more spectacular fashion than Pacquiao did then I will consider Dinamita to be the superior boxer/fighter. Boom!

[JOM'S]

Both won another lineal title and a couple paper belts. Both guys beat some decent fighters. No way should JMM's loss to PBF count against him. But Pac's win on Cotto beats any of JMM's wins, so Pac edges it.

very good reply, very agreable ...