My P4P 30

[IwatchBoxing]

Too many Mexicans shouldnt have anything to do with it and tell me who is better than Winky and PBF and who they beat that makes them better?

Well, their happens to be alot of Mexicans on the top ten when their are other fighters out there better.

My top ten.. (would look like this)
1.James Toney
2.Mayweather
3.Winky Wright
4.Bernard Hopkins
5.Zab Judah
6.Diego Corrales
7.Barrera
8.Ricky Hatton
9.Antonio Tarver
10.Jermain Taylor

[Cali_Rob]

I agree.....

I respect opinions, and I wanted opinions.....but I also wanted reasoning behind the opinions so Ill ask again...whats bad about it?

[Easy-E]

Heres my P4P top 30, all legitimate comments and feeback welcome.

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Winky Wright
3. Marco Antonio Barrera
4. Diego Corrales
5. Jose Luis Castillo
6. Manny Pacquaio
7. Rafael Marquez
8. Juan Manuel Marquez
9. Antonio Tarver
10. Zab Judah
11. Bernard Hopkins
12. Erik Morales
13. Kostya Tyszu
14. Zahir Raheem
15. Ricky Hatton
16. Jermain Taylor
17. Glen Johnson
18. Cory Spinks
19. Joel Casamayor
20. Antonio Margarito
21. Martin Castillo
22. Oscar Larios
23. James Toney
24. Jean Marc Mormeck
25. Fernando Vargas
26. Ricardo Mayorga
27. Jeff Lacy
28. Roman Karmazin
29. Miguel Cotto
30. Shane Mosley

whats bad??
zab in top ten, lacy at 27, hopkins at 11, taylor at 16,
hatton at 15, tarver in top ten and zoo at 13.
i also dont liek jmm and rafel at 7 + 8 but i guess u can make a case

[Parodius]

I respect opinions, and I wanted opinions.....but I also wanted reasoning behind the opinions so Ill ask again...whats bad about it?

Your top 5 to being with. Also putting Margarito ahead of James Toney is a joke. Having Taylor 16 is another, too many more. But that's all for now.

[IwatchBoxing]

Tell me why these fighters deserve to be on a top ten list..
to begin with..
5. Jose Luis Castillo (lost to casa, Mayweather, and Corrales)
7. Rafael Marquez (who?)
8. Juan Manuel Marquez (draw with Pac?)

[Cali_Rob]

Well, their happens to be alot of Mexicans on the top ten when their are other fighters out there better.

My top ten.. (would look like this)
1.James Toney
2.Mayweather
3.Winky Wright
4.Bernard Hopkins
5.Zab Judah
6.Diego Corrales
7.Barrera
8.Ricky Hatton
9.Antonio Tarver
10.Jermain Taylor

Your P4P aint bad but you still didnt answer my question..... You said my top two fighters werent that good, (but yet you have them in your 2 and 3 spots) and I asked who is better than them? and who have they beat to proove why they are better than them? And you come up with James Toney......dont get me wrong I think James is a bad ass but your reasoning dosent really make any sense.

[IwatchBoxing]

Your P4P aint bad but you still didnt answer my question..... You said my top two fighters werent that good, (but yet you have them in your 2 and 3 spots) and I asked who is better than them? and who have they beat to proove why they are better than them? And you come up with James Toney......dont get me wrong I think James is a bad ass but your reasoning dosent really make any sense.

I didnt mean the top two pound for pound, and anwser my question above...

Tell me why these fighters deserve to be on a top ten list..
to begin with..
5. Jose Luis Castillo (lost to casa, Mayweather, and Corrales)
7. Rafael Marquez (who?)
8. Juan Manuel Marquez (draw with Pac?)

[oj21]

I guess you just wanted to share who you think are the top thirty. It's a pretty good list I don't know if it's a bad list, I mean it is after all your list and your opinion. I would disagree with some of your choices, but not all of them. Now about being too long maybe for a P4P list, so maybe you should have said "My top thirty fighters". I don't understand what the hell "too many Mexicans in your top ten" have anything to do with it being a bad list, **** I could make a top ten list with nothing but Mexicans and it still wouldn't be a bad list. Why? Because it's my list, and I could put anyone I want in it.

[Cali_Rob]

whats bad??
zab in top ten, lacy at 27, hopkins at 11, taylor at 16,
hatton at 15, tarver in top ten and zoo at 13.
i also dont liek jmm and rafel at 7 + 8 but i guess u can make a case

Zab is in the top 10 because he is the undisputed 147 champ until proven otherwise by Margarito.....Lacy is at 27 because he is a champion and and is beating legitimate opposition with ease but hasnt beat another champ or established 168 fighter and will work his way up the the P4P rankings.....Hopkins is at 11 because he has put in work dominating his division but lost a close fight(which I thought he won but should have won more convincingly) with a true middleweight in Taylor......Hatton is at 15 because he beat Kostya Tyszu but I wasnt really impressed with the way he beat him and in my opinion he would lose in a rematch....Tarver is in the top 10 cause he beat the P4P champ at the time and also beat most of the competition at lightheavy....Kostya is at 13 cause he is the former undisputed champ and has beaten better opposition than Hatton and again I think he will bounce back and beat Hatton in a rematch on nuetral grounds.

[Cali_Rob]

I didnt mean the top two pound for pound, and anwser my question above...

Tell me why these fighters deserve to be on a top ten list..
to begin with..
5. Jose Luis Castillo (lost to casa, Mayweather, and Corrales)
7. Rafael Marquez (who?)
8. Juan Manuel Marquez (draw with Pac?)

JLC deserves to be in the MY top 10 because he beat Julio Diaz, Juan Lazcano, Joel Casamayor(but I can see why people think Cas won) and most importantly of all hes the only fighter to beat PBF. Rafael Marquez belongs because he is without a doubt the best fighter 118 and down. JMM belongs because he drew with Pac but in my opinion would beat Pac in a rematch and he will dominate his division until some of the prospects mature and JMM ages a bit.