Where would you rank Manny ATG wise if he were to beat Floyd and Sergio?

[kymira]

Top 5 but like everybody stated...no catchweights

[Modobo3]

Without question...if he were to beat PBF at 147 - and unfortunately he has to take the tests...this would erase all doubt... Then beat Martinez at 154!!!

Holy ****!!!

Now those would be some Epic fights!!!

If not #1... On the Mt. Rushmore for sure.

This is what I'd expect in an ATG...

Let me be clear, and "fortunately" for us, PBF must now fight Martinez before his career ends or it will be incomplete...because if Pac must fight him to secure his place among the all time greats, so should PBF.

Man, could you imagine the wars between these three...not to mention the possible rematches and trilogies.

Peace Mo!

[Mr. Philadel]

*******s following their big brothers, the *****s, asking "what if" questions, when their idol is thinking of fighting other lesser fighters.


Mayweather is Pac's big brother. *****s are *******s big brothers.


Mayweather fought Judah, DLH, Hatton, Mosley...Little brother follows in big brothers footsteps.

*****s talk about how business comes first, talking about fantasy fights, bringing up shoulda woulda coulda situations....*******s follow in big brother *****'s footsteps.

How sweet.

[Steak]

It would be huge. they would both be the best victories of his career.

I dont have a ATG list, but I can tell you right now Pacquiao would gain a LOT of respect legacy wise, how much depends on how he does it.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Seriously anyone who says anything over Top 25 is a fool.

Go research History. He could beat Martinez, Floyd, Ortiz, Khan and Bradley and he still wouldnt crack the Top 5 even. A bunch of noobs on this site.

1. Ali
2. Armstrong
3. SRR
4. Louis
5. Greb/Pep/Langford


I man who would Pac replace? Lets be real here.

[SlickTurtle]

Pacquiao fans already rate Manny as a ATG, some of them say that his first 15 wins make him a ATG.

So really there is no need to ask this question.

Are you saying Manny ain't an ATG?

[fitefanSHO]

My Top 10 ATG...

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Muhammad Ali
4. Joe Louis
5. Roberto Duran
6. Willie Pep
7. Archie Moore
8. Ray Leonard
9. Marvin Hagler
10. Rocky Marciano

No idea how PacMan ever cracks this list tho he is an ATG for sure.

Top 50? Yes. Top 25? Maybe. Top 10? No freakin way.

[Mr. Philadel]

Seriously anyone who says anything over Top 25 is a fool.

Go research History. He could beat Martinez, Floyd, Ortiz, Khan and Bradley and he still wouldnt crack the Top 5 even. A bunch of noobs on this site.

1. Ali
2. Armstrong
3. SRR
4. Louis
5. Greb/Pep/Langford


I man who would Pac replace? Lets be real here.

this^^^^^^^^

[horge]

I'll differ with any hold-the-legends sacred sentiment, and point
out that it is paper stats that ultimately count, shorn of all fanboy
hoopla and 'intangibles' that we today take for granted, as firsthand knowledge. Much of what most know TODAY about past legends
like SRR, Armstrong, etc is really second-hand knowledge.

I'm a little more charitable with Pac's ATG place.
Right now I have him possibly inside of 20.
If he chooses the right opponents he ight make it barely into top 15.

Even WITHOUT beating Floyd or Sergio.
Again, paper stats: Floyd offers no belts, and neither will Sergio if
it'll be (as likely) at a catchweight.

[Pacdbest]

My Top 10 ATG...

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Henry Armstrong
3. Muhammad Ali
4. Joe Louis
5. Roberto Duran
6. Willie Pep
7. Archie Moore
8. Ray Leonard
9. Marvin Hagler
10. Rocky Marciano

No idea how PacMan ever cracks this list tho he is an ATG for sure.

Top 50? Yes. Top 25? Maybe. Top 10? No freakin way.

You must be one of the most ****** Member of this Board! You should join Teddy Atlas Moron & ****** Club! Pac's a top 10 Locked since he dominated DLH! Pac's Just 1 or 2 wins away to be the GOAT!